Fears the proportion of Australian home borrowers in negative equity will double
More Australians forced to sell face owing their bank more than their home is worth.

The proportion of Australian borrowers trapped in a mortgage prison is likely to conservatively double as house prices continue to tumble until 2029, a leading property expert says.
Australia’s capital city weekend auction clearance rate plunged to 44 per cent - the worst figure since April 2020 during the early weeks of national pandemic lockdowns, real estate data group Cotality has revealed.
The success rate of homes selling above the reserve price was also significantly below the 63.1 per cent level of a year ago when buyers were responding to Reserve Bank rate cuts instead of aggressive rate hikes.
Sign up to The Nightly's newsletters.
Get the first look at the digital newspaper, curated daily stories and breaking headlines delivered to your inbox.
By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.Opposition Leader Angus Taylor said the worst auction clearance results since the start of the COVID pandemic was a poor reflection on Labor’s changes to negative gearing and capital gains tax concessions.
“Labor has this country on the path to economic ruin, and we’re seeing the impact of their toxic taxes right now,” he told reporters in Canberra on Monday.
“We’ve seen it over the weekend in the housing market, with the lowest auction clearance rates in the housing market since COVID.
“This is an atrocious — a catastrophic — situation in our housing market where we’re seeing a collapse in confidence, we’re seeing rising rents, we’ve seen a reduction in construction.”
The RBA estimates that just 1 per cent of borrowers are now in negative equity, where they owe their bank or their lender more than their home is worth as a result of falling property prices.
But Mansour Soltani, the head of research with real estate professionals comparison site OurTop10, said that figure could conservatively double, as a property market recovery was pushed out to 2029.
“I would expect so. We don’t think we’re at the peak of this trough — from what the data’s showing us, we’re looking at potentially being halfway through this before we even start seeing any sort of green shoots,” he told The Nightly.
“From peak to trough, you’re probably talking about three years - I would expect to start seeing shoots of green in 2029.
“There’s going to be more pain to come, people need to be able to weather the storm and the ones that can’t are going to start selling.”
An increase in unemployment could force borrowers to sell, which would be a particularly bad situation for someone who took out a mortgage during the past three years.
“They’re very sensitive to any sort of seismic shifts such as business closing down that you work for, you losing your job — the timing of it could not be worse,” Mr Soltani said.
Areas of high mortgage stress, where borrowers can’t pay their bills, also had lower auction clearance rates in the key markets of Sydney and Melbourne which more traditionally invite bids from prospective borrowers.
Gosford and Wyong are regarded as the worst suburbs in New South Wales for mortgage default risk in an OurTop10 report.
The NSW Central Coast also had a dismal auction clearance rate of 38.1 per cent which was significantly below greater Sydney’s 48.1 per cent auction clearance rate.
Median house prices in both these suburbs have also fallen by 6 per cent during the past three months, Cotality data showed, making them danger zones should there be more forced sales.
Outer suburbs of Melbourne with soaring mortgage default risks also had low auction clearance rates.
Deer Park was regarded as a rising default risk is in Melbourne’s west where the auction clearance rate stood at just 45.1 per cent, below greater Melbourne’s 47.8 per cent level, which was the worst since September 2021.
Rising mortgage stress levels could also potentially see apartment owners struggle to pay quarterly strata fees to unit complex body corporates who organise repairs and maintenance, Owners Corporation Network managing director Chris Irons said.
“That is a real risk that that could happen - in economically tight times, it’s possible that there will be challenges in getting body corporate levies paid,” he told The Nightly.
“That in turn means that maintenance might also be in some jeopardy.”
The Commonwealth Bank, Australia’s biggest mortgage lender, noted falling home prices would be unlikely to make life easier for first dual-income homebuyers facing higher variable mortgage interest rates.
“While lower prices and continued income growth have provided some relief, this has been partly offset by higher mortgage rates,” senior economist Trent Saunders said.
“Affordability has improved slightly in most capitals since around the middle of the year, but mortgage-servicing burdens remain high by historical standards.”
Middle-market house prices in Sydney have fallen 9.3 per cent since peaking earlier this year, which was steeper than Perth’s 9.2 per cent, Brisbane’s 8.5 per cent, Melbourne’s 6.3 per cent and Adelaide’s 4.4 per cent.
