analysis

The Victorian Labor Party has left a $33 billion Budget landmine for State’s likely next premier Jess Wilson

The Victorian Liberal leader is likely to take charge of one of the most precarious budgets in the nation, forcing her to make difficult decisions that will define her government.

Headshot of Aaron Patrick
Aaron Patrick
The Nightly
Liberal Party leader Jess Wilson will win government with a four-seat majority according to an average of opinion polls.
Liberal Party leader Jess Wilson will win government with a four-seat majority according to an average of opinion polls. Credit: News Corp Australia

A paradox lies at the heart of the Victorian Labor Party’s expected removal from office after this month’s election: the underlying cause of its defeat could offer a path back to power.

Daniel Andrews and his successors’ parting gift to Liberal leader Jess Wilson is one of the most precarious budgets in the nation. There’s an out-of-control $33 billion Budget deficit over four years, 400,000 state employees and $100b in construction projects that became sheltered workshops for the CFMEU’s favourite bikies.

“It’s been atrocious,” is how independent economist Saul Eslake describes Labor’s budget management. “And it’s not getting better.”

Sign up to The Nightly's newsletters.

Get the first look at the digital newspaper, curated daily stories and breaking headlines delivered to your inbox.

Email Us
By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.

If she wins, fixing the finances will be Ms Wilson’s toughest and most important job, which helps explain why she chose not to offer any more election bribes on Sunday at the opposition’s campaign launch.

Clearly a masochist, Ms Wilson has promised to serve as her own treasurer for at least the first 100 days of government, underscoring the importance she places on budget repair.

“I can’t remember an election where there’s been such an intense focus on the need to pay down debt,” she said on Sunday.

Victorian political parties have announced three election policy pledges targeting women voters two days before early polling opens.

When it comes to the Budget, the political arithmetic is ugly.

Balancing the books, at least in the medium term, would require spending cuts, which would provide ample material for a Labor opposition to campaign leading up to the 2030 election.

In this campaign, the Coalition has promised about $8b in extra spending over four years, from 25 new diesel-electric trains to a Geelong bus station. To pay for them, Ms Wilson has promised spending cuts and asset sales worth, on average, about $2.6b a year.

Delivering these savings, which mostly come from a public service hiring freeze, would be difficult. Last week the Labor Party distributed a Parliamentary Budget Office analysis that estimated the hiring freeze would save $8.5 billion over the initial six years, a sum too small to meet the Coalition’s balanced budget target of 2032.

Ms Wilson said she would not “be taking lectures on costings from a Labor government”.

Lines of attack

Although many voters tune out at the mention of the federal Budget, Victorians see a direct connection to their experiences of government services.

“It cuts across people’s perceptions there isn’t enough money to fix roads and that their experience in the health system is there isn’t enough money there,” says Kos Samaras, a political pollster associated with the Labor Party. “It used to be nebulous, abstract.”

The threat is likely to intensify. If interest rates around the world continue rising, Victoria’s $200b debt could easily trigger another credit-ratings downgrade. A Wilson government would either have to cut services or take on even more debt than it already plans to. Tax cuts would be fiscally irresponsible.

The Labor Party is already working on its lines of attack. Deputy premier Gabrielle Williams says the Coalition is “promising” to fire 32,000 public servants, including paramedics, and cut spending by $40 billion. Both assertions are untrue.

But objective data does indicate Victoria has too many public servants and spends too much.

According to Mr Eslake, calculations by the Commonwealth Grants Commission, which helps allocate GST revenue, indicate Victoria spends $5.4b a year above what is necessary to match services offered in other states. It also spends $1.8b more on infrastructure than the rest of the country, thanks to the mega-road and rail projects begun under ex-premier Andrews that have become infested with corruption.

On Monday, it was reported that a company accused of bribing a West Australian public servant is a contractor on a large Melbourne freeway project. Richard Carroll, a director of earthworks contractor VicFlow, hung up the phone when asked by The Nightly to comment on eight corruption charges filed against him by the West Australian Police and the Corruption and Crime Commission last month.

The Victoria Infrastructure Delivery Authority said it was “seeking assurances from our head contractor that they are reviewing whether this company remains appropriate to continue working on the project.”

The building industry’s problems have helped create a perception among many Victorians that the Andrews and Allan governments increased spending without adequate controls. The Victorian public sector grew 45 per cent between 2013–14, when Labor won power, and 2023–24.

The population increased by less than half that rate over the same period.

Premier Ben Carroll and his wife greet supporters at Sunday’s campaign launch.
Premier Ben Carroll and his wife greet supporters at Sunday’s campaign launch. Credit: News Corp Australia

Presumably concluding that he won’t have to pay for it, Premier Ben Carroll on Sunday promised 100,000 additional elective surgeries in public hospitals. At a cost of $1.2b, it is the third most-expensive Labor Party promise of the campaign behind $3.6b to improve local roads and $1.5 billion for hospital emergency departments.

Even though most individuals’ medical costs are the responsibility of Medicare, a federal program, Mr Carroll on Monday promised a rebate of up to $500 to test pregnant women’s foetuses for down syndrome and other abnormalities.

“Liberals will Americanise our health system, but I’ll make it more affordable,” he said.

Broken promises syndrome

The Budget and political situation is similar to 1992, when Liberal leader Jeff Kennett won power after 10 years of a big-spending Labor government. He closed schools, sacked public servants and sold off assets, including the State’s power companies.

Despite huge protests organised by the union movement, Mr Kennett was re-elected in 1996.

Voters may be less forgiving, though, making it harder for a Wilson government to administer the tough medicine the state needs.

What could be called the broken promises syndrome — anger at politicians perceived to have lied to voters — was demonstrated when Prime Minister Tony Abbott’s 2014 Budget proposed modest charges for doctors’ consultations. A backlash contributed to the Liberal leader’s removal from office the following year. This year’s decision by the Albanese Government to increase taxes on investors led to a big fall in his popularity too.

Despite the Labor Party’s predictions that Ms Wilson will have to govern in a coalition with One Nation, polls and betting markets predict her only partner in government will be the Nationals.

An analysis published Monday morning by forecasting start-up politicks.io predicted the Coalition will win a four-seat majority. One Nation will win 12 seats, the Labor Party 20 and the Greens seven, according to the model, which is based on public polls. Voting opens Wednesday.

As for Ms Wilson, she told The Nightly repairing the Budget will be challenging, but she is committed to balancing spending and revenue.

“I won’t pretend fixing 12 years of Labor’s financial mess will be quick or easy, but Victoria cannot keep borrowing more and expecting families to pay the price,” she said.

“If we have the honour of being elected, we’ll open the books, rein in back-office bureaucracy and stop wasteful spending, while protecting the essential services Victorians rely on.”

Comments

Latest Edition

The Nightly cover for 13-11-2026

Latest Edition

Edition Edition 13 November 202613 November 2026

Cummins slams ‘friend’ Khawaja as he dismisses bombshell Sandpapergate claims as ‘100 per cent wrong’.