Benjamin Jack McLaughlin: Naked man found on boat accused of murdering good Samaritan in Cervantes, WA

The alleged murder ended with the accused being found naked on a castaway ship.

Emma Kirk
NewsWire
Not Supplied
Not Supplied Credit: Supplied

A mobile phone being used as a torch has incidentally recorded an alleged murder that ended with the accused found naked on a castaway ship, a court has been told.

Benjamin Jack McLaughlin, 22, will face trial over a string of bizarre incidents near the small fishing town of Cervantes, about 200km north of Perth in September 2023.

A fisherman spotted a naked Mr McLaughlin acting erratically on a boat adrift in water off the Cervantes Jetty.

Sign up to The Nightly's newsletters.

Get the first look at the digital newspaper, curated daily stories and breaking headlines delivered to your inbox.

Email Us
By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.

The accused ended up in the water and was rescued by a fisherman before he was taken into custody and given medical treatment.

Nearby, a small red car was submerged in water.

Murder victim John Matta’s car was found submerged in the ocean at Cervantes, about 200km north of Perth. Picture: 7NEWS
Murder victim John Matta’s car was found submerged in the ocean at Cervantes, about 200km north of Perth. 7NEWS Credit: News Corp Australia

That same morning police discovered the human remains of John Matta inside a burnt-out white Mitsubishi Pajero that had been found ablaze off Indian Ocean Drive.

Mr McLaughlin pleaded not guilty to Mr Matta’s murder, casting away ships, arson and stealing a car in March this year.

At a Supreme Court hearing on Wednesday, Mr McLaughlin’s lawyer Christian Porter said they were waiting for a psych report to further understand any issues ahead of a trial set down for February next year.

Benjamin McLaughlin was found naked on a cray boat. Picture: ABC
Benjamin McLaughlin was found naked on a cray boat. ABC Credit: Supplied

Mr Porter told the court an unusual feature of the case was the axe that caused Mr Matta’s death was recorded on a mobile phone being used as a torch.

He said given the nature of the footage, there could be issues around mental illness.

Mr Porter said when his client was taken into custody his mental state was very poor and he remembered very little from the time.

Mr McLaughlin is set to face trial in the WA Supreme Court from February 8 next year.

Latest Edition

The Nightly cover for 14-05-2026

Latest Edition

Edition Edition 14 May 202614 May 2026

Will PM be tempted to fish out more of Shorten’s unpopular ideas?