The world’s best pizza for 2024 isn’t in Naples – or even in Italy. It’s in New York

Forrest Brown

CNN

4 Min Read

21 Sep 2024

Many New Yorkers will gladly tell anyone who’ll listen — and even those who won’t — about how they have the best pizza.

And now they’ve got some mouth-watering new back-up for their long-standing culinary claims.

Last week, the Italy-based 50 Top Pizza Awards came out with its 2024 worldwide list, and a Lower East Side New York restaurant came out on top.

Get the first look at the digital newspaper, curated daily stories and breaking headlines delivered to your inbox.

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.

Una Pizza Napoletana, opened by pizza maestro Anthony Mangieri in March 2022, not only beat other US competitors but also global ones. That includes pizzerias in Naples, Italy — the holy land for pizza aficionados and foodies in general.

“It’s inspiring to be recognised for this 30 years into my career, especially in Naples where pizza originated,” Mangieri said.

Adding to New Yorkers’ bragging rights, three other Big Apple pizzerias made the 2024 list, which included 101 restaurants in total (despite the “50” in the name of the awards).

New York pizzerias Ribalta ranked No. 19, Don Antonio No. 30 and L’industrie Pizzeria No. 80.

Italy still managed to dominate the overall list with 41 eateries, while a total of 15 United States places were recognised.

And Naples managed to best New York with five entries on the list, including a tie for the No. 2 spot with Diego Vigtaliano Pizzeria.

Showing how truly global the awards are, nations not exactly known for their pizza scenes — South Korea, Bolivia and India, to name three — were represented on the list.

Why Una Pizza Napoletana?

The 50 Top Pizza Awards explained how Una nabbed the highest honour.

“In a country always accustomed to putting everything on pizza, Anthony proposes only the purest tradition in toppings with extraordinary quality ingredients,” the Awards website said.

“Marinara, margherita, cosacca, and a pizza that changes every day, based on market ingredients.”

Mangieri, who grew up in New Jersey, developed “a pizza obsession at a young age,” a media representative for the restaurant told CNN Travel.

Una Pizza Napoletana in New York makes the world’s best pizza, according to the 50 Top Pizza Awards. Credit: CNN

His mother ended up driving him to all the well-known pizza spots in New Jersey, New York and Connecticut in his quest for the “perfect pizza”.

Mangieri “focuses on naturally leavened, wood-fired pizzas with ingredients like the best San Marzano tomatoes, Amalfi wild oregano, buffalo mozzarella DOP, and Sicilian sea salt,” the representative said.

“He chose to have only one location to allow for an obsessive focus on every detail.”

Dough emphasis

Mangieri focuses on the basics to achieve his results.

“What makes a really good pizza is first the dough. It’s not a specific recipe but it’s about hydration and understanding how to work the dough and being able to adapt to all the variables involved,” he told CNN Travel.

“At Una, what makes us different is our dough is naturally leavened and highly hydrated, never refrigerated, made with a mixture of many different of Italian flours, and I make the dough every day we’re open.”

Una Pizza Napoletana should appeal to the “slow food” crowd. It bakes only three pizzas at the time in its wood-fired ovens.

The current location at 175 Orchard St, just off Houston St, is actually the sixth iteration of the restaurant and has been open since March 2022.

For people more about frozen sweets than hot pizza, the 50 Top Pizza Awards also praised the homemade ice cream and seasonal sorbets at Una.

As far as the acclaim goes, Mangieri said: “The recognition is appreciated, but in the end it’s not why I started and not why I continue to make every ball of dough we serve at Una after all these years. It fuels us to go into the restaurant every day and give more love and focus, and not to take anything for granted.”

And what does this pizza master enjoy eating himself? “Pasta, and I eat it for almost every meal. Or my fiancee’s Mexican cooking.”

If you’re hoping to drop by for a pie at Una, you’ll have to wait until October 4. Mangieri and his team have closed the place while they travel in Italy.