Charming Rottnest Island, or Wadjemup, boasts the finest beaches in Australia and encapsulates low-key luxury

Some islands announce themselves with a trumpet blast of mythology. Think Capri, Ibiza, Mykonos and the other Euro players swollen by a level of self-regard usually reserved for ageing rockers or men who sport neckerchiefs.

Then there’s Rottnest Island, sitting off Perth like a sun-kissed cousin who wandered barefoot out of a pub and accidentally became charming.

See, Rottnest — Wadjemup or Rotto, to use its true local titles — is all sorts of brilliant because it seemingly doesn’t understand its own appeal. On Rotto there’s no overstocked marinas of wealth or streets clogged by influencers in linen or a DJ named Luca assaulting the air with Italian disco at 2pm.

No, this is an island that does island life as it always has — a place that hums to a simple rhythm of bikes and bare feet, the country’s finest beaches (fact) and quokkas grinning at you like a drunk uncle from across the wedding reception.

Read the latest edition of ROAM here.

Here, on Wadjemup, days pleasantly dissolve into nothingness, framed by lowkey itineraries that don’t deviate far beyond experiencing some truly transparent waters and slices of sand that social media often projects as a Euro dupe. And they’re right to project this way — except here the crowds are comparatively lacking (though we won’t suggest Rotto doesn’t claim its share of peak numbers across summer and especially school holidays). Still, a January visit sees ROAM finding daily solitude and coves and beaches to share with very few, if any.

The luxury of Rottnest is arguably psychological. There’s no traffic and no urgency. Here, kids play in a 50s fever dream devoid of devices: hopscotch chalked in front of the so-called heritage cottages that still dominate the island’s main settlements, cricket games organised between strangers because they can, with bikes cycled to a point of necessary repair.

We chose electric and you’d be wise to do the same. While there’s freedom in properly pedalling, there’s also rather taut thighs by day’s end while the afternoon winds can present more pushback than a 14-year-old on an 11pm curfew. As for the midday sun, it can be oppressive in the height of summer.

It’s why the trick to Rottnest — which sits a mere 30 minutes off Perth by fast ferry, departing Fremantle’s B Shed or the north’s Hillarys Boat Harbour for $90-100 per adult return — is to move early and resist the urge to do everything.

You’ll score a bike in the settlement — that is, the main hub of Thomson Bay — and head out before the heat arrives. Again, the roads are blissfully free of cars, save the bus service set on a clockwise loop, with the ocean appearing and disappearing between the scrub.

Stop wherever the water looks indecently blue. Little Salmon Bay is one of the finer places for a swim and a morning snorkel, with calm waters and an abundance of marine life close to the shore and across its accessible reefs. From here, head for the seals and the remote and rugged ways of the West End (though know this is also the point where Rottnest starts to remind you that bicycles have no sympathy for middle-aged ambition) or across to the smaller “township” (that means a shop and a cafe) of Geordie Bay, using the wind’s direction to dictate an afternoon around the striking Fay and Longreach bays.

Heading back to Thomson Bay means cycling through The Basin, a sheltered natural swimming hole that’s something of a Rottnest institution and which also does half-decent dining thanks to the Mediterranean menus of Havza.

There will, inevitably, be quokkas — the island’s unofficial celebrities, although they seem considerably less impressed by their fame than the tourists are. With the Dutch having landed here in the 17th century, it was Willem de Vlamingh who named “Rottenest” in 1696 after mistaking quokkas for giant rats. To continue this sharp history lesson, from 1838, the island became a penal establishment for Aboriginal men and boys with thousands imprisoned in brutal conditions and many never returning home. Wadjemup Museum is a solid look at the punishing history of the place which later served as a military base, internment camp and holiday destination before becoming the postcard version of Western Australia it is today.

As for those quokkas, well, they’ve managed to emerge from it all as the island’s aggressively cheerful PR department, though it’s also worth noting the focused efforts around truth-telling and laying bare the harsh realities that came to encircle the Whadjuk Noongar people, and the deep significance the island holds as a place of ceremony and spiritual connection.

The main hub of Thomson Bay — Thommos the seemingly localised abbreviation — is rather tiny though enables enough. That means a supermarket and bakery (the $14 crayfish pie is better than it sounds, the Reuben sandwich a solid outing and the whole roast chook the best value), with the Mezz cafe overlooking alongside a smattering of boutiques as well as a Subway and Dome chain cafe and ice creamery.

The award-winning Isola Bar e Cibo is a popular Italian restaurant (best to book) and an island stand-out. Dinner here means eyeing the breadth of those who head for Rottnest, from some well-presented western suburbs types (read: Perth money) to camping families eager to sample something other than a BBQ sausage one night. Portions here are sizeable, the blue swimmer crab pasta worth the price of admission, with crisp, cold drinks served with a side of sparkling water views.

Time on Rottnest must also include time at Hotel Rottnest, known as “the pub”. It has informed the settlement since the island’s earliest tourism days, its beer garden exactly where you want to be as the afternoon cools and the sun dips.

Eat, sleep, swim, nap, drink, read, swim some more, repeat — Rottnest days come grafted to a very simple and gentle cadence that’s unlike anywhere else. And the brilliance and unique allure that it holds comes framed by a sense of romance that winks to the past, of 50 years ago.

It’s not to paint the scrubby outpost into an unsophisticated corner — far from it, and certainly not with the arrival of The Lodge and its recently completed $50 million renovation that saw the final touches, the addition of the hypnotic pool and Poolhouse rooms, finalised late last year.

ROAM’s elevated Lakeside room sits adjacent to the pool and holds the goods when it comes to a glistening outlook across Garden Lake (one of 12 salty bodies of inland water on Wadjemup) to the lighthouse — the space a study in an easy coastal aesthetic, all light, white and soft timbers, duck-egg blue bathroom with pops of brass, and a balcony on which to sit and slink into a given day. It’s the kind of styling that whispers “effortless” despite clearly costing a fortune.

The Lodge’s pool, framed by red striped lounges, umbrellas and a certain sense of the Med, maintains a temperature of 28 degrees while the open and expansive main restaurant of Sunsets works menus across the day, dinner proving the best time to indulge and take in those named views, local produce and a few cocktails.

The power and the pull of Rottnest is built twofold. Here life comes stripped back to its better essentials as held across a peculiar set of rules — bikes instead of cars, quokkas over commuters, salt water in place of schedules. And this sense of easy and unique freedom is precisely why it is Australia’s best island break.

thelodgewadjemup.com; rottnestisland.com