JENI O’DOWD: Australia’s ‘world-first’ kids social media ban now lagging behind
JENI O’DOWD: If kids’ social media ban is what’s keeping Albanese from dumping Anika Wells as Communications Minister, he shouldn’t bother.

Travel-loving Communications Minister Anika Wells has survived four breaches of the parliamentary expenses rules. If only her social media ban were as hard to get around as she is to get rid of.
Remember the family flights and a hire car from Toowoomba to a footy match in Sydney? Wells repaid $10,116, including a penalty, and kept her job. A trip to Adelaide, conveniently timed so she could attend a friend’s birthday party, was cleared.
So why is the Prime Minister protecting her? Daily Mail political editor Peter van Onselen argued it’s because she’s the face of the much-hyped world-first social media ban for kids under 16.
Sign up to The Nightly's newsletters.
Get the first look at the digital newspaper, curated daily stories and breaking headlines delivered to your inbox.
By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.Albo, if that’s the reason, don’t bother.

Not only is the ban not working, other countries are doing it better than we are.
And it wasn’t even her idea. A year ago, Wells told everyone the Albanese Government would get kids off social media in a “world-first”. The idea actually came from SA Premier Peter Malinauskas, who pushed for it first.
“Australia, a continent so far away and now yet so far ahead when it comes to online safety,” she gushed the day the ban started, after spending about $190,000 of taxpayers’ money to spruik it to the UN in New York.
The ban is a year old on December 10, and yes, more than 20 countries have copied it, or are planning to, with many going even further. We haven’t.
A review by the eSafety Commissioner found 81.5 per cent of under-16s were still using at least one banned platform three months after the ban started.
Before it, the figure was 85.9 per cent. About half the kids surveyed who were still on social media apps said the platform had never checked their age.
And the ones who were checked? They found a way around it, exactly as many, including myself, predicted.
Some kids borrowed a parent’s face to get through facial recognition. One Reddit thread claimed a printed mesh face mask from Temu could fool the scanners. Others used a VPN, or moved to apps the ban didn’t cover.
Wells’ response was to double the maximum fine for platforms that failed to keep kids off to more than $100 million. That’s all well and good, except not a single fine has been issued. Not one.
The ban in Turkey began earlier this month. Infinite scrolling and autoplay are restricted, as well as personalised ads and behaviour-based profiling.
Accounts have to stay private. And significantly, age isn’t verified by a platform guessing from a selfie, but by a token from a government portal.
Britain, which starts its own under-16 ban next year, has also gone further than Australia.
Livestreaming and messaging strangers will be switched off for under-16s on gaming platforms and social media, and AI chatbots that simulate romantic or sexual relationships will be off-limits for anyone under 18.
Indonesia’s ban includes Roblox, which Nebraska’s attorney general called a “playground for predators”. Ours does not.
There’s another thing to consider as well. Last week, the Australian Federal Police revealed children now make up 40 per cent of its active counter-terrorism cases.
When it studied 55 cases involving 12 to 17-year-olds, all of them had been radicalised at least partly online.
One AFP commander said research suggests a young person can be shown violent extremist material within 23 minutes of logging on.
The platforms Home Affairs Minister Tony Burke named included Discord and Roblox. Neither are covered by Australia’s ban.
Last Friday, Burke opened a $76 million centre in Sydney to hunt down online extremism, with gaming platforms squarely in its sights, admitting the social media ban was “helpful” but not enough.
So the Government is spending tens of millions chasing radicalisation on the very platforms our own ban lets kids use. I mean, are they serious?
The goal with the social media ban was always admirable. Nobody wants to see kids radicalised, hounded or bullied.
But the fact is, the Government passed a world-first law and bragged about it, while leaving enforcement to the very companies that profit from keeping kids scrolling.
Perhaps Anika Wells could spend a little less time on planes and in hire cars and a little more time reading what other countries have done, and how we can do more.
