exclusive

MITCHELL JOHNSON: I don’t see how Pat Cummins remains Australian captain amid Cameron Bancroft revelations

The heat on Pat Cummins is now immense following Cameron Bancroft’s sandpaper tell-all, and the public pressure for him to stand down as Test captain now will be too much, writes Mitchell Johnson.

Mitchell Johnson
The Nightly
Cameron Bancroft has released a detailed 4,500-word account of the 2018 Sandpapergate scandal, claiming the entire Australian cricket team knew about the ball-tampering incident.

There’s so much to unpack in Australian cricket, and I don’t think I’ll be finished unpacking it any time soon.

Cricket Australia announced a forum, a “safe space” for those from the 2018 tour to speak. Within hours, Cameron Bancroft created his own safe space, and this one the public could hear.

Bancroft named the fast bowlers. Really, he named the whole team and staff.

Sign up to The Nightly's newsletters.

Get the first look at the digital newspaper, curated daily stories and breaking headlines delivered to your inbox.

Email Us
By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.

He said the final straw was Pat Cummins’s press conference last week. You could feel it. The anger, disappointment, and grievance he’s held onto all these years were too much to keep holding. He’d had enough, and he got his account of that time across.

CA’s forum may have ended on the same day it was announced. It didn’t feel like it was going to achieve much when I first heard about it. It’ll be interesting to see whether it keeps going now.

I believe Bancroft’s account. It comes across as real and I could feel the words as he was saying them. He came across as himself and he has nothing to lose now. It also lines up with the most detailed accounts we’ve heard from other players.

The pressure on Cummins is now immense. I think he will still try to stand by what he has said and his statement with all of the bowlers back in 2021.

But I think the public pressure for Cummins to stand down as Test captain now will be too much. I just can’t see how his captaincy and personal brand survives this.

It feels like support for Cummins and Mitchell Starc, Josh Hazlewood and Nathan Lyon and their version of events is now at its lowest point.

And it’s all affecting our summer of cricket already.

A couple of things caught my eye this week. Cooper Connolly was asked about sandpaper and the players involved before the final one-day international against England. He doesn’t need those questions. He was in school when it happened.

Connolly should be enjoying this, playing cricket for Australia, the game that’s meant to be passed on to the next generation with joy and excitement.

Then the Australian captain, Mitch Marsh, didn’t front the presser after the series. That job went to Jack Edwards, a young, inexperienced player left to take on the media.

Marsh did the on-ground interview with Adam Gilchrist, but it looked and felt awkward, and it stayed on the series loss to England.

So where does this go now? It’s only going one way, and that’s not changing anytime soon.

We’ve been told the culture has changed since 2018. Has it? From the outside it might look that way. If you want to change a culture, you have to take accountability first. Plenty of people have said just move on. I asked why recently. I think we’re starting to find out.

CA needs to do more than a safe-space forum. It’s owed to the fans, and they’ve had enough, like many of us.

Mitchell Johnson

This isn’t good for any of the players involved. I don’t think it’s good for anyone who’s played the game, because it puts all of our integrity in question.

It puts Cummins’ 70-minute press conference in question. It puts the brand and profile players have built since 2018 in question. It asks again why only four bowlers signed that statement? The coaches and what they knew is in question again. It’s one big ball of knots.

There’ll be variations of what happened in 2018. Everyone remembers things a little differently. But in the end, the truth is the truth.

I don’t have all the answers. I used to be angry, annoyed and frustrated, and I struggled with the gut feeling that we were never told the full story. Journalists will have a field day. Podcasts will give us the good, the bad and everything in between. Former players will do the same, me included.

CA needs to do more than a safe-space forum. It’s owed to the fans, and they’ve had enough, like many of us. The investigation failed at the one thing it was meant to do, end this eight years ago with the right outcome. We want the truth, we want answers. But we also wish we had moved on all that time ago.

The act of using sandpaper was wrong. But what followed was the truth not being told, the brotherhood not being a brotherhood, blokes thrown under the bus and the he-said, she-said that still won’t stop. That has made it bigger than it ever should have been.

For a former player who loved playing for Australia, it’s disappointing. That pride and joy, the best job in the world, now feels crushed with what’s happening to the game of cricket when spoken about. It isn’t a familiar place anymore.

I hope the next generation doesn’t let this take anything from them. It’s their dream, and their family and friends get to watch them grow. They can create their own culture.

Cameron Bancroft has released a detailed 4,500-word account of the 2018 Sandpapergate scandal, claiming the entire Australian cricket team knew about the ball-tampering incident.

Comments

Latest Edition

The Nightly cover for 19-11-2026

Latest Edition

Edition Edition 19 November 202619 November 2026

Pat Cummins’ captaincy under a cloud after Cam Bancroft’s explosive tell-all sends shockwaves through Aussie cricket.