analysis

AARON PATRICK: In an election he is losing, Russia’s aggression will allow Peter Dutton to show who he is

Aaron Patrick
The Nightly
The Liberal leader has warned Russia is a threat to the West and Australia for years. Now is his chance, writes Aaron Patrick.
The Liberal leader has warned Russia is a threat to the West and Australia for years. Now is his chance, writes Aaron Patrick. Credit: MICK TSIKAS/AAPIMAGE

Sometimes in politics when you take a stand on principle, events reward you.

Tuesday’s revelation that the Federal Government may have learned of Russia’s request for an air force base in Indonesia from the internet gives Liberal leader Peter Dutton the opening his losing campaign desperately needs.

A former defence minister, Mr Dutton was an immediate, consistent and trenchant critic of Russian’s 2022 invasion of Ukraine.

Sign up to The Nightly's newsletters.

Get the first look at the digital newspaper, curated daily stories and breaking headlines delivered to your inbox.

Email Us
By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.

While some on the right in Australia and overseas, including Donald Trump, expressed sympathy for Vladimir Putin’s complaints about NATO expansionism, Mr Dutton warned Russia was a threat to the liberal world order.

That was before anyone in Australian public life imagined Russian might want to place bombers within range of Darwin.

Peter Dutton said the Greens decision to hold a dance party showed the party’s disrespect for the defence force. Picture: Richard Dobson / Newswire
Peter Dutton said the Greens decision to hold a dance party showed the party’s disrespect for the defence force. Richard Dobson / Newswire Credit: News Corp Australia

Exploiting incompetence

Even if Indonesia refuses to grant the Russians an air base -- their military cooperation dates almost to independence in 1949 -- the request is such a hostile act that it may, at least temporarily, capture the election campaign.

Normally, crises play to the government’s strengths. Unlike the opposition, which is confined to words, ministers are capable of action.

In this case, the government’s apparent failure to know more about what is happening in Jakarta than a military trade journal in London is an example of incompetence that Mr Dutton can and will exploit.

“Obviously,” Mr Dutton said Tuesday, “surely they must have known about this before it’s been made public.”

This situation -- a potential physical threat to mainland Australia -- is why intelligence agencies were given $2 billion this year. It is the reason Australian Signals Directorate and Australian Secret Intelligence Service exist. It is why defence attaches are assigned to every significant diplomatic outpost.

The crew aboard a Russian Su-34 bomber has been killed after it crashed in the Caucasus region. (AP PHOTO)
The crew aboard a Russian Su-34 bomber has been killed after it crashed in the Caucasus region. (AP PHOTO) Credit: AAP

Our war too

Australia is, indirectly, a participant in the Ukraine war. Defence Minister Richard Marles has overseen $1.3 billion of military aid to Ukraine, including M1 Abrams tanks the army is replacing with newer models.

Hundreds of Australians have been placed on Russian sanctions lists, including journalists such as myself.

The Russian air force has shown it is a killing machine that does not distinguish between military and civilian targets.

SUMY, UKRAINE - APRIL 13: Police and rescue workers operate at the site of a Russian ballistic missile strike on the city centre, killing many civilians on April 13, 2025 in Sumy, Ukraine. The death toll after Russian ballistic missiles' attack on the center of Sumy has risen to 34, including two children. At least 117 people have been injured, including 15 children. On Palm Sunday, the Russian army launched two ballistic missiles with cluster munition at the central part of the city at a time when there were many people on the streets - dozens of people were killed and injured in the city; civilian infrastructure and residential buildings were damaged or destroyed. (Photo by Denys Kryvopyshyn/cukr.city/Global Images Ukraine via Getty Images)
SUMY, UKRAINE - APRIL 13: Police and rescue workers operate at the site of a Russian ballistic missile strike on the city centre, killing many civilians on April 13, 2025 in Sumy, Ukraine. The death toll after Russian ballistic missiles' attack on the center of Sumy has risen to 34, including two children. At least 117 people have been injured, including 15 children. On Palm Sunday, the Russian army launched two ballistic missiles with cluster munition at the central part of the city at a time when there were many people on the streets - dozens of people were killed and injured in the city; civilian infrastructure and residential buildings were damaged or destroyed. (Photo by Denys Kryvopyshyn/cukr.city/Global Images Ukraine via Getty Images) Credit: Global Images Ukraine/Global Images Ukraine via Getty

Russian aggression is one part of Australia’s security challenge. China is a Russian ally, and on Monday two Chinese prisoners-of-war were displayed by the military in Kiev.

This second security surprise for the government, which was alerted of a February Chinese navy exercise in the Tasman Sea by Virgin Australia, highlights that Australia is not so far from powerful forces that some serious analysts and historians fear could shift from a trade war to a physical one.

Bribe-a-thon

Mr Dutton, participating in what has become a bribe-a-thon campaign, now has an opportunity to explain to a disengaged electorate one of the central distinctions with his opponent.

The Liberal leader is a true foreign affairs hawk. He regards authoritarian states such as China and Russia as threats to Australian security and, in the long term, prosperity.

If expansionist Russia wants a permanent military presence closer to Australian than Bali, then Australians entire perceptions of their regional security may change -- showing Mr Dutton has the most valuable trait a leader can possess: prescience.

Comments

Latest Edition

The Nightly cover for 15-04-2025

Latest Edition

Edition Edition 15 April 202515 April 2025

Russia has entered the election group chat.