Geelong star Bailey Smith responds to Mad Monday backlash after Mitch Brown said ‘Heath Ledger’s way hotter’

Kimberley Braddish
The Nightly
Bailey Smith has fired back at backlash after he was criticised for a number of social media posts
Bailey Smith has fired back at backlash after he was criticised for a number of social media posts Credit: Instagram/bazlenka

Geelong star Bailey Smith has fired back after he was criticised for his social media posts during Geelong’s Mad Monday antics.

The AFL’s first openly bisexual player Mitch Brown called out Smith’s series of controversial Instagram posts during the Cats’ end-of-season celebrations, particularly an image of Smith and Patrick Dangerfield referencing the film Brokeback Mountain, captioned, “this is what losing a granny does to ya.”

Smith captioned the clip: ‘or brokeback mountain depends how ya look at it’ and ‘this is what losing a granny does to ya.’
Smith captioned the clip: ‘or brokeback mountain depends how ya look at it’ and ‘this is what losing a granny does to ya.’ Credit: Instagram/bazlenka

Sign up to The Nightly's newsletters.

Get the first look at the digital newspaper, curated daily stories and breaking headlines delivered to your inbox.

Email Us
By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.

In response, Brown posted a picture of Heath Ledger from Brokeback Mountain, writing, “Just for the record, Heath Ledger’s way hotter.”

Mitch Brown slammed Bailey Smith.
Mitch Brown slammed Bailey Smith. Credit: Instagram @mitchbrownie

He then followed up with another pointed remark: “Last time I checked, losing a Grand Final doesn’t make you gay, but being homophobic definitely makes you a loser.”

Mitch Brown’s Instagram story.
Mitch Brown’s Instagram story. Credit: @mitchbrownie

On Monday night, Smith appeared to reply with an Instagram story of Ledger raising his middle finger.

Smith appeared to reply with an Instagram story of Ledger raising his middle finger.
Smith appeared to reply with an Instagram story of Ledger raising his middle finger. Credit: Instagram/bazlenka

The fallout comes amid further controversy, with veteran journalist Caroline Wilson blasting Smith for an “insulting and sexist message” after he mocked her in a now-deleted Instagram post.

During the celebrations, Smith’s teammate Max Holmes arrived dressed as Wilson, a moment Smith posted online with the caption, “Caro has never looked better,” paired with a sweat droplets emoji.

Smith later added a photo with Holmes, captioning it “Caro has never looked better,” before quickly deleting the post.
Smith later added a photo with Holmes, captioning it “Caro has never looked better,” before quickly deleting the post. Credit: Instagram/bazlenka

Wilson’s criticism follows her previous comments, branding Smith a “brat” after an incident involving a female photographer at a training session.

Amid the drama, Geelong’s football boss Andrew Mackie addressed the club’s position, stating, “Obviously, we’re not perfect. We don’t stand here and pretend to be … Every now and then, there’s things that pop up that ideally don’t, but we can only learn and educate from here our players and our people.”

Mackie dismissed reports that the club had lost track of Smith, saying, “No, that wasn’t all factual – I was aware what he was up to.”

He reiterated confidence in the club’s management of Smith, adding, “But, like I said, I get the interest in Bailey. But him playing footy this year is a real success story for the game … we’re all not perfect. We’ve just got to continue to keep working together and those little moments that might bubble away, we’ve just got to keep on educating.”

Comments

Latest Edition

The Nightly cover for 06-10-2025

Latest Edition

Edition Edition 6 October 20256 October 2025

What now for the Liberal Party.