Sonia Exelby murder case: Music tutor lured from UK to US by ‘sadist’ killer Dwain Hall, court told

A jury has heard harrowing details about how a Florida man lured a British woman who wanted to die to the US after meeting her on a hardcore fetish website.

Matthew Quagliotto
The Nightly
Dwain Hall, 54, has been accused of murdering Sonia Exelby, 32, whose body was found in a shallow grave in Florida.
Dwain Hall, 54, has been accused of murdering Sonia Exelby, 32, whose body was found in a shallow grave in Florida. Credit: supplied/Marion County Sheriff's Office/F

A music tutor with a lengthy history of mental health issues flew from her UK home to meet a Florida man accused of her murder after she offered to pay him $US4000 ($6000) to end her life, a US court has been told.

Sonia Exelby, 32, had spent two years contacting 54-year-old mechanic Dwain Hall through a hardcore fetish website before they finally met in person in October, 2025, the Daily Mail reported.

Those discussions reportedly included an offer from Exelby to pay Hall to kill her.

Sign up to The Nightly's newsletters.

Get the first look at the digital newspaper, curated daily stories and breaking headlines delivered to your inbox.

Email Us
By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.

However, prosecutors allege that after landing in the US and heading to a Florida Airbnb with Hall, Exelby attempted to back out of the grim pact.

They allege that Hall, who used the moniker Alphasadist on the website the pair met on, Motherless, was hell-bent on seeing their agreement through and did so - beating and abusing Exelby before eventually stabbing her to death.

Messages between Exelby and Hall, who is charged with kidnap and murder, in the months leading up to her ill-fated trip were shown to a jury at Marion County Judicial Centre in the Florida city of Ocala on Wednesday.

Those discussions on the extreme website, Motherless, included one in which Exelby, typing under the moniker AlreadyYours, tells Hall “I can’t be without you” and how much “I’ve missed my alpha more than I can imagine”.

Assistant state attorney Amy Berndt told the jury in her opening statement that Exelby’s online infatuation with Hall emerged as a “substitute” for the self-harm her mental health issues often drove her to, Metro reported.

“Unfortunately, she found another outlet … about two years before her death, and ultimately that outlet would lead to her murder,” Ms Berndt told the jury.

Ms Berndt said Exelby was “brutally murdered by a predator, a man who called himself Alpha Sadist, a man who was sexually aroused by the rape and torture of women.”

“That man is the defendant Dwain Hall.

“Sonia Exelby was a beautiful, kind woman who was deeply loved by everyone who knew her. But sadly, she suffered from mental illness for most of her life.

“She met the defendant online and he manipulated her for years. He targeted her because of her mental illness and he exploited her for his own sadistic pleasure.”

Ms Berndt said Hall had “groomed Sonia, he wanted the job of being her executioner.”

Music tutor Sonia Exelby who was found dead in a shallow grave in Florida in October, 2025.
Music tutor Sonia Exelby who was found dead in a shallow grave in Florida in October, 2025. Credit: supplied/Facebook

According to Metro the pair had already unsuccessfully tried to meet in order for Hall to kill Exelby in March 2025.

“After that fell through, the defendant realised, ‘Hey, not only can I kill her, but I might as well get some money from it as well’,” said Ms Berndt.

“And he told her that she had to bring 4,000 dollars with her when she actually came here for him to kill her.”

After scheduling another meeting, this time in Florida in 2025, Exelby booked both the trans-Atlantic flight and a remote rental property.

However, once it took off, her second thoughts began and the court heard how her UK partner of 16 years Stevie Hunt - who believed that Exelby was off visiting her sisters - found a harrowing email two days later that she had sent herself from her flight. It talked about “sorrow, depression, regret and death”, Ms Berndt told jurors this week, according to The Daily Mail.

“As soon as the wheels leave the ground, I wish I was home, can’t get off the plane… I want to beg for help so badly,” it read.

“Oh god, I feel so sick… why am I here, why? If I wasn’t numb I’d never have gotten out of the house, this would be impossible, although I’m hurting more than I ever have.”

Mr Hunt contacted UK authorities on October 12, who alerted US law enforcement but by then it was too late. Hall was tracked down after charges on Exelby’s credit cards were made by his breakdown company.

Her body, bearing four stab wounds and bruising marks was found in a shallow grave in Florida’s Marion County by US police in Florida on October 17.

Hall denies kidnapping or murdering Exelby, instead arguing that the pair had rough but consensual sex at an Airbnb.

However, police allege that Hall had posted a knife, found to be bearing Exelby’s blood, to an acquaintance. The also allege that he had tried to delete nude images and a video of the UK 32-year-old from his phone, which was also found to have a tranche of images and videos of women being tortured.

The trial continues.

LIFELINE 13 11 14

BEYOND BLUE 1300 224 636

Latest Edition

The Nightly cover for 18-11-2026

Latest Edition

Edition Edition 18 November 202618 November 2026

Not just for nerds: Game launch set to be a productivity-killing, internet-breaking cultural phenomenon.