Australian news and politics recap April 22: Dutton, Albanese face off for third leaders debate

Peta Rasdien and Max Corstorphan
The Nightly
Peter Dutton has been declared the narrow winner over Anthony Albanese in the third leaders debate.
Peter Dutton has been declared the narrow winner over Anthony Albanese in the third leaders debate. Credit: Alex Ellinghausen/NCA NewsWire

Scroll down for the latest news and updates.

Key Events

So who won the debate? The verdict is in
PM uses final pitch to say Labor will protect Aussie from Coalition cuts
Dutton sticks to key talking points in final pitch to voters
Leaders credit each other on their care for their families and dedication to politics
Both leaders reject Greens in the event of minority government
Awkward: Dutton slams PM for rejecting debate requests...during debate
Albanese makes his final pitch
Dutton admits nuclear isn’t a vote winner but says he’s ‘committed’
Both leaders commit to protect free television for Australians
PM challenged over budget claims and spending cuts
Debate gets fiery over recession language
Leaders speak on their personal tone in campaign
I’m ‘tough’ not ‘wishy washy’ says PM
Dutton rolls out key campaign messages
PM denies he is trying to win by default
PM accuses Coalition leader of ‘nonsense’ over tariff claim
Dutton still thinks he can do better US deal
PM spruiks his housing plan
Dutton’s dire warning for negative gearing, renters under Labor-Greens coalition
PM slams Coalition cost-of-living measures
Dutton ‘wants to be the Prime Minister of home ownership’
PM asked about home insurance spikes
PM ducks tough questions on energy bills
Dutton grilled over fuel excise ‘sugar hit’
Dutton says he’s more Howard than Trump
Opposition leaders point to fuel pledge and housing policy as women-focused plans
We want people to be better off in three years time: Albanese
PM denies he’s lost appetite for bold reform after Voice failure
Dutton labels Labor’s ‘Mediscare’ campaign a lie Australians won’t fall for
PM dodges question on unprecedented number of soft voters
PM gives his opening pitch
Dutton opens third leaders debate talking on cost of living
Albanese and Dutton minutes away from third leaders debate
Peter Dutton thanks family ahead of debate
Dutton is ‘losing women in modern electorates’: teal MP
Chaney asked about fellow independent’s Sky brush-off
How Labor hopes to woo women’s votes
Decision to go ahead with leaders’ debate the right call: Burke
Leo DiCaprio, Whoopi Goldberg lead celeb tributes for Pope
Independent Kooyong MP Monique Ryan involved in awkward exchange at prepoll
New polling shows women and young voters deserting the Coalition
Dutton: ‘This is a moment of mourning’
Dutton, Cosgrove attend Sydney Mass to mourn Pope Francis
Dutton heads to Sydney Church service
Albanese holds back emotion as he discusses three faiths
Who will represent Australia at Pope Francis’ funeral?
Albanese says Pope Francis ‘one of the most consequential leaders’
Dutton’s plans cancelled for key Nationals seat
‘Today’s not the day’: Politics on hold as Australia mourns Pope Francis
Pope Francis’ death reshapes Labor’s campaign focus
PM Albanese pays tribute to Pope Francis at St Patrick’s Cathedral in Melbourne
Parties warned over late policy reveals
Australians begin voting as policies remain unannounced
Nicola Smith

So who won the debate? The verdict is in

The verdict is in from Channel 9 panel on who won the debate…?

First up is 2GB’s Deb Knight, who says Peter Dutton edged it over Anthony Albanese.

“I think that they both performed very strongly. They were both very relaxed. They were both not just sticking to the talking points, but showing a bit more of humanity, which is what we wanted to encourage in this debate,” she says.

Ms Knight praised Mr Dutton for making strong and clear points and for debating with confidence.

It was “very, very close,” but he won over the PM when he needed to, she says.

Phil Coorey, the AFR’s political editor, says Mr Dutton won a number of fronts, including on the cost-of-living, where he was more precise and made points that were easier to digest.

“He had to come from further behind and he had to do better,” he says, but Mr Coorey still gives the victory to the PM by “half a percent” as Mr Dutton lost his composure at the start of the debate.

With the deciding vote, Charles Croucher, political editor at 9News rules the winner is Peter Dutton – “by a nose!”

Mr Dutton had his best of three debates tonight, he says.

“He brought his best cost of living material today and his facts down pat.”

Caitlyn Rintoul

Debate gets fiery over recession language

Both leaders have been in a spin around who would be the best economic manager.

Opposition leader Peter Dutton was asked about where he would make cuts in his “economic surgery” to restore the budget.

While responding he accused the Labor Government of trashing the budget and only having some positives to tell because they have “benefited from a variation in the commodity prices”.

“That means that the prices of iron ore and our other commodities have gone up, and that’s what’s given the government a bigger revenue than expected,” he said.

He accused them of being the biggest spending government in four decades.

“That’s what has led the Reserve Bank Governor to warn Australians and to warn this government that our home grown inflation problem is of the government’s making,” he said.

Mr Dutton went on to say: “The Prime Minister spoke before about interest rates coming back.

“They’re not looking like they’re coming back any time soon… unless they throw us into a recession.”

After his remarks, Anthony Albanese piped up at his wording.

He accused the Liberal leader of putting words in the RBA Governor’s mouth and making “extraordinary comments” on a recession.

“The leader of the Opposition just made an extraordinary comment, which exemplifies one of the things this election is about - him talking Australia down,” Mr Albanese said.

“He just talked about recession and said that was inevitable - said that was the only way the interest rates would come down.

“He verballed the Reserve Bank.”

Mr Dutton interjected and fired back: “PM let me tell you, you are loose”.

Max Corstorphan

Albanese holds back emotion as he discusses three faiths

The Prime Minister has often spoken of being brought up with three faiths: the Catholic Church, the South Sydney Rabbitohs and the Australian Labor Party.

He became emotional answering questions about the personal effect of the pope’s death, although he acknowledges he generally tries not to speak about his religious faith in public.

“At times like this, I think what people do is draw on who they are. Catholicism is just a part of me,” he says.

“And one of the things about the Holy Father is that … I think his humility, for the way that he embraced the poor, the way that he embraced the social justice message that I see as the message of Jesus Christ, is really important for so many Catholics.

“He was someone who I personally admired… He had a great deal of courage as well. He was very much a modern leader in the way that he conducted himself.”

Mr Albanese added he believes it is very important that Australia has a secular democracy.

Max Corstorphan

Who will represent Australia at Pope Francis’ funeral?

Anthony Albanese has spoken with Governor-General Sam Mostyn, who was already headed to Turkey to attend the dawn service at Gallipoli on Anzac Day.

She is likely to stay in Europe and attend the Pope’s funeral to represent Australia.

He’s also spoken to former Nationals MP Keith Pitt, who was appointed as Australia’s ambassador to the Holy See earlier in the year.

Because of the Pope’s illness, Mr Pitt has yet to present his credentials and formally start in the role but he is making arrangements.

Max Corstorphan

Albanese says Pope Francis ‘one of the most consequential leaders’

Anthony Albanese has spoken from parliamentary offices in Melbourne to again pay tribute to Pope Francis.

He says the Pope will be mourned not just by Catholics but by people from all walks of life.

“In the truest sense of the words, he practised what he preached,” the Prime Minister said.

“The Holy Father was one of the most consequential leaders of this century and indeed our lifetime.”

Mr Albanese says he will suspend the rest of his campaigning for the day. Peter Dutton has done the same.

Earlier this morning, Mr Albanese attended a service at St Patrick’s Cathedral in Melbourne.

Max Corstorphan

Dutton’s plans cancelled for key Nationals seat

The Nightly’s Latika M Bourke reports that Opposition Leader Peter Dutton was due to campaign with the Nationals Candidate Sam Farraway in Orange in the seat of Calare in regional New South Wales.

Mr Dutton’s intention to campaign in the once-held Nationals electorate is unusual but reflects the fierce contest underway for the seat.

Former Nationals MP Andrew Gee held the seat before defecting to the crossbench.

He is fighting to retain it as an Independent but is fending off a strong campaign by teal Kate Hook and Mr Farraway.

Max Corstorphan

‘Today’s not the day’: Politics on hold as Australia mourns Pope Francis

Anthony Albanese and Peter Dutton are still expected to front the third leaders’ debate on Tuesday night, but the Prime Minister and Opposition Leader have cancelled planned events for Tuesday.

The Opposition Leader has said “today’s not the day for big politicking”.

Mr Dutton says he will spend the day “reflecting” instead of engaging in “overt politicking” on Tuesday, out of respect for Pope Francis.

Both leaders have indicated that although voters will head to the booths from Tuesday, there will be disruptions to campaigning in light of the death of Pope Francis.

“I don’t think there’s any need for over-the-top politics today. I think we can respectfully put our positions,” Peter Dutton said.

Although when asked about the news polls that found voters’ biggest concern about the Coalition was his personality, the Opposition Leader said his party was focused on law and order, fuel price cuts and getting young people into homes.

“We have a chance to course correct to get the country back on track and that is what we are concentrating on,” he said.

“That is what the election will be contested on – not the personalities and mud being thrown by Labor.”

Anthony Albanese also indicated that his plans have changed today so that he can pay respect to the Pope and show his support for members of the Catholic community.

Kimberley Braddish

Pope Francis’ death reshapes Labor’s campaign focus

The death of Pope Francis is set to loom large over Anthony Albanese on the election campaign trail, as the Prime Minister leads tributes to the pontiff.

The Prime Minister, a devout Catholic, praised the late Pope as an inspiration who as also committed to peace, following his death on Monday after a battle with pneumonia.

“For Australian Catholics, he was a devoted champion and loving father. Pope Francis lived out his faith and vocation in work and deed,” he told reporters.

“The memory and example of his compassion will long endure as we mourn his death.”

The Pope’s death is expected to overshadow domestic issues on the campaign trail, with the prime minister beginning his day in Melbourne.

Read the full story here.

Kimberley Braddish

PM Albanese pays tribute to Pope Francis at St Patrick’s Cathedral in Melbourne

The Prime Minister has started his day at St Patrick’s Cathedral in Melbourne.

There is a portrait of Pope Francis at the front of the cathedral, near the altar and some floral tributes have already been laid on it

Mr Albanese was greeted at the entrance to the cathedral by Monsignor Stuart Hall.

Service usually runs for 30 minutes but may go a little bit longer due to the Pope’s death.

Max Corstorphan

Parties warned over late policy reveals

Both major parties have promised to release the full costing of their policies before May 3.

Coalition MPs have defended delaying policy announcements until late in the campaign, saying they will unveil them when Australians are paying the most attention.

But that approach could come back to bite the party if 2022’s early voter turnout of more than 5.5 million people is anything to go by.

Analysts expect many voters going away for the upcoming Anzac Day long weekend and school holidays will take advantage of pre-polling, meaning parties may have to change tack.

“If they’ve got something that they want to have a maximum impact, they can’t reveal it at the last minute the way they used to,” University of Tasmania public policy associate professor Kate Crowley told AAP.

Pre-polling is becoming more popular as voters turn away from major parties, which means Labor and the coalition need to strategise about how election sweeteners are offered during a campaign, she said.

Max Corstorphan

Australians begin voting as policies remain unannounced

Political hopefuls are running out of time to unveil and sell their major policies as Australians begin to cast their votes in the federal election.

The first ballots will be cast on Tuesday as early voting begins ahead of the May 3 poll, with millions expected to skip the lines on election day.

It’s sparked warnings about parties not having enough time to sell their messages if they keep policies up their sleeves for too long.

The Coalition still has at least one major announcement to come on its defence spending allocation, while it is yet to specify what public service jobs are on the line as it aims to reduce the commonwealth payroll by 40,000 people.

Labor has seized on the Coalition not balancing its spending with enough cost-saving measures to launch attacks about “secret cuts” as it campaigns heavily on Medicare and other health initiatives.

“When Peter Dutton cuts, Australians will pay,” has been the government’s tagline, which was used again on Monday by Prime Minister Anthony Albanese in a visit to an urgent care clinic in the marginal NSW south coast seat of Gilmore.

Mr Albanese called it “extraordinary arrogance” for the Opposition Leader not to tell Australians where all the flagged cuts will come from until after the election.

Mr Dutton has said he needs the resources of Government to determine areas of waste to be targeted.

Comments

Latest Edition

The Nightly cover for 15-05-2025

Latest Edition

Edition Edition 15 May 202515 May 2025

Democrats rocked by new book which claims aides hid extent of Biden’s decline.