Beauty and the Geek’s Tamika Sueann Rose Chesser flags mental health defence in beheading murder case
A reality TV contestant will seek to mount a mental health defence after pleading not guilty to the beheading murder of her partner.
A reality TV contestant accused of beheading her partner has pleaded not guilty to murder, flagging a mental health defence.
Tamika Sueann Rose Chesser, who was runner-up on Beauty and the Geek in 2010, allegedly decapitated Julian Story, 39, and disposed of his body in June 2025.
She was charged with murder and destroying human remains to pervert the course of justice after Mr Story’s dismembered body was found at the couple’s home at Port Lincoln on South Australia’s Eyre Peninsula on June 19, 2025.
Sign up to The Nightly's newsletters.
Get the first look at the digital newspaper, curated daily stories and breaking headlines delivered to your inbox.
By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.Chesser appeared in Adelaide Magistrates Court via video link on Tuesday to enter pleas to the charges.
Her lawyer, Rosie Denny, conceded there was a case to answer and entered not guilty pleas on her client’s behalf.
Part 8A investigations were to take place, the court was told, referencing the process in which a defendant can raise a mental impairment that affects their criminal responsibility or fitness to stand trial.
Magistrate John Clover committed former reality TV star to the Supreme Court for arraignment on November 2.
Chesser was in November reported to have been pregnant at the time of her arrest and gave birth in early 2026.
She is being held under a mental health detention order at psychiatric facility James Nash House in Adelaide.
The charges were finalised earlier after prosecutors received a post-mortem report, crime scene analysis, including fire examination and blood pattern analysis, DNA evidence and forensic analysis of phones owned by Chesser and Mr Story.
Police found Mr Story’s body after firefighters were called to the Flinders Highway property to investigate reports of a blaze.
Detective Superintendent Darren Fielke issued a plea for public help on June 27, 2025, “because tragically, we have not recovered the head of Julian Story”.
Police released still images and video of a woman they allege was Chesser walking on Port Lincoln streets that were recorded after the killing, which investigators allege occurred about midnight on June 17.
The images show a woman wearing a black headscarf and black full-body coverings, carrying a bag.
A Port Lincoln resident told police on July 31 they had found a skull in scrub while pursuing a wandering dog.
Forensic tests later confirmed it was Mr Story’s skull.
