'Game-changer' ruling to target dodgy business tactics after High Court uses Captain Cook College as example

Holly Hales
AAP
The High Court ruled a college used a dodgy incentive scheme to help recruiters sign up students.
The High Court ruled a college used a dodgy incentive scheme to help recruiters sign up students. Credit: AAP

Corporations could now be held directly responsible for predatory business models following a landmark court decision.

The High Court case involved the vocational institute Captain Cook College, which hired marketers to sign up students for its online courses, tempting them with gifts such as free laptops.

The college initially had processes to weed out students who would be unable to take on study, but abandoned those systems when recruiters complained they meant they did not make as much money.

Sign up to The Nightly's newsletters.

Get the first look at the digital newspaper, curated daily stories and breaking headlines delivered to your inbox.

Email Us
By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.

This resulted in students, many from disadvantaged backgrounds, becoming liable for substantial debt for courses they never started.

At the same time, the college’s profits soared from $326,000 to $18.9 million.

Professor Elise Bant from Melbourne Law School said the implications of the decision could extend to many aspects of corporate wrongdoing, including harms that occur through AI.

“Corporate fraud and predatory behaviour are common, harming consumers, fair traders and society as a whole,” Professor Bant said.

“Yet, as the Banking Royal Commission showed, too often corporations are structured to allow them to avoid or limit responsibility, to hide behind excuses of ‘system errors’ and ‘incompetence’.”

The new principle potentially also applies to both corporate groups and government entities, “so public entities could be held to account for systemic abuses such as Robodebt”.

Professor Bant said the decision was “a game-changer” and would force corporations to “think through their systems”.

“This is a practical way of unmasking corporate fraud and predatory practices,” she said.

Comments

Latest Edition

The Nightly cover for 18-02-2025

Latest Edition

Edition Edition 18 February 202518 February 2025

Chalmers declares victory in rates relief battle but Bullock warns war on inflation far from over.