Middleton Beach, South Australia: Teenage boy bitten by shark while surfing at Fleurieu Peninsula

A 16-year-old surfer said he was lucky to escape serious injury after a shark reportedly bit his foot over the Easter weekend.

Andrew Hedgman
NewsWire
A great white shark larger than four metres circled a fishing boat off the coast of Robe, South Australia, forcing terrified fishermen to return to shore.

A 16-year-old boy has recounted a close encounter with a shark that reportedly bit his foot while surfing at Middleton Beach in South Australia on Friday.

Oliver Tokic-Bensley said he was sitting alone on his board when he felt something grab his foot.

“I felt something sharp … I sort of jumped when it got me and then I kicked my foot away and luckily it didn’t hold onto me,” he told the ABC.

Sign up to The Nightly's newsletters.

Get the first look at the digital newspaper, curated daily stories and breaking headlines delivered to your inbox.

Email Us
By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.
Oliver Tokic-Bensley was surfing alone at Middleton Beach when he says a shark grabbed his foot. Photo: Supplied
Oliver Tokic-Bensley was surfing alone at Middleton Beach when he says a shark grabbed his foot. Photo: Supplied Credit: Supplied Source Known

For a brief moment, the Year 11 student feared the attack could be fatal.

“I was like ‘oh s**t, (it) might come back and bite me somewhere else’,” he said.

Oliver said he then spotted a fin in front of him and assumed it was a bronze whaler because of its colour.

He paddled nervously about 70 to 100m back to shore, expecting the shark to follow.

“I thought it was going to come back and bite me again,” he said.

“I was hoping it wasn’t chasing me.”

Once onshore, Oliver called his sister and his parents, who were holidaying in the area over Easter, rushed down to check on him.

“They were pretty shocked,” he said.

Authorities said the bite may have been caused by a juvenile shark, but the species is unconfirmed. Photo: Supplied
Authorities said the bite may have been caused by a juvenile shark, but the species is unconfirmed. Photo: Supplied Credit: Supplied Source Known

He even took photos of his bite to show his friends.

Although the injury didn’t require an ambulance, Oliver went to hospital, where staff cleaned and bandaged the wound without needing stitches.

Despite the scare, Oliver said he was not afraid of sharks and would continue surfing once his foot healed.

“It’s all part of it. I went in there knowing there was a chance,” he said.

“It’s worth the risk.”

Looking back on the ordeal, Oliver said it added a thrill to his weekend.

“It was pretty exciting … sort of made my Easter weekend.”

Oliver (left) said he feels "lucky" to still have his foot after the attack. Photo: Supplied
Oliver (left) said he feels "lucky" to still have his foot after the attack. Photo: Supplied Credit: Supplied Source Known

South Australia Police confirmed they received a report of the bite.

Shark Watch SA founder Anton Covino told the ABC the mark on Oliver’s ankle might have been from a juvenile shark, but it was unclear what species caused the bite.

“There’s no real clear indication that there is a jaw around his ankle … but judging by the teeth marks, we can’t say what shark it is entirely,” Mr Covino said.

He also urged swimmers to avoid the water at dawn and dusk.

Comments

Latest Edition

The Nightly cover for 02-04-2026

Latest Edition

Edition Edition 2 April 20262 April 2026

We’ve got Trump’s war and Albo’s answers.