‘Vindicated’ Linda Reynolds takes Commonwealth, HWL Ebsworth to court over Brittany Higgins’ $2.4m settlement

Rebecca Le May
The Nightly
Linda Reynolds is constantly being approached by people backing her relentless pursuit of reputation repair, even overseas, her lawyer says.
Linda Reynolds is constantly being approached by people backing her relentless pursuit of reputation repair, even overseas, her lawyer says. Credit: Justin Benson-Cooper/The Sunday Times

Linda Reynolds is constantly being approached by people backing her relentless pursuit of reputation repair, even overseas, her lawyer says.

After the former Liberal senator won her epic defamation case against Brittany Higgins in August, she pushed ahead with moves to have her former staffer and husband David Sharaz declared bankrupt, in a bid to secure huge damages and court costs.

And on Wednesday, the ex-politician had her first case management hearing in the Federal Court against the Commonwealth’s $2.4 million settlement with Ms Higgins.

Sign up to The Nightly's newsletters.

Get the first look at the digital newspaper, curated daily stories and breaking headlines delivered to your inbox.

Email Us
By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.

The payment was over Ms Higgins’ claim her former boss mishandled her allegation she was raped by colleague Bruce Lehrmann at Parliament House in Canberra in 2019.

Ms Reynolds just before finding out she had won her bitter defamation case against her former staffer in August.
Ms Reynolds just before finding out she had won her bitter defamation case against her former staffer in August. Credit: Ian Munro/The West Australian

The mishandling allegation was at the heart of the defamation case, centred on social media posts by the couple in 2022 and 2023.

Ms Reynolds was now feeling “reputationally, very much vindicated”, her lawyer Martin Bennett told reporters outside court.

“And that’s reflected in the fact that she can’t walk in public without people stopping her and telling her how much they admired her tenacity,” Mr Bennett said.

“She was overseas for some defence matters and people were uniform in their congratulations to her.

“Now it’s just a matter of seeking financial vindication.”

Ms Higgins claims she’s now broke, Ms Reynolds’ lawyer Martin Bennett told a separate bankruptcy hearing in the same court on Tuesday.
Ms Higgins claims she’s now broke, Ms Reynolds’ lawyer Martin Bennett told a separate bankruptcy hearing in the same court on Tuesday. Credit: AAP

The next court hearing on the bankruptcy bid for Ms Higgins is on November 18 and December 16 for Mr Sharaz.

No next court date has yet been set for Ms Reynolds’ fight with the Federal Government and the legal firm it engaged to handle the settlement, HWL Ebsworth, while an amended statement of claim is lodged.

Ms Reynolds, who was not present in court on Wednesday, has argued Ms Higgins’ allegations about her were defensible but she was entirely excluded from the process.

Mr Bennett said the settlement “gave rise to a perception that everything that Brittany Higgins ... (said) about her was true”.

“So this is the last matter to resolve,” he said.

Lawyer Martin Bennett arrives at the Federal Court on Wednesday.
Lawyer Martin Bennett arrives at the Federal Court on Wednesday. Credit: Sandra Jackson/The West Australian

“They’ll have a period of time until December to work out whether or not they apply to try and strike it out for summary judgment, and if not, they’ll put on defences ... by 6 February or something along those lines.

“It’s a simplified claim to try and press it through - essentially a negligence action.”

On Ms Higgins’ reported claims she had no money left, Mr Bennett said he would “deal with it at face value”.

The Federal Government is being represented by Ruth Higgins SC and HWL Ebsworth by solicitor Natalie Donnan, who both appeared via videolink.

Mr Lehrmann continues to maintain his innocence after his 2022 rape trial was aborted due to juror misconduct and the charge was then dropped.

In a subsequent defamation case against Network Ten and journalist Lisa Wilkinson that he lost in 2024, he was found to have raped Ms Higgins, based on the balance of probabilities, which is the standard of proof in civil cases.

He is appealing that finding.

1800 RESPECT

Sexual Assault Counselling Australia 1800 211 028

Comments

Latest Edition

The Nightly cover for 11-11-2025

Latest Edition

Edition Edition 11 November 202511 November 2025

Whitlam is most famous for his political demise. But his legacy helped define modern Australia.