analysis

Economist Saul Eslake proposes raising compulsory super as an alternative to aggressive interest rate hikes

Economist Saul Eslake has suggested temporarily raising compulsory employer super contributions to 13 per cent to tackle high inflation without inflicting more pain on borrowers.

Headshot of Stephen Johnson
Stephen Johnson
The Nightly
Australia's migration policy debate intensifies as economic forecasts warn that One Nation's proposed cuts could push the country nearly $300 billion further into debt by reducing the workforce by roughly 800,000 taxpayers.

Australian workers could have their compulsory employer super contributions temporarily raised so there’s less money in their bank accounts to tackle high inflation amid fears more aggressive interest rate hikes risk pushing up employment and sparking a recession.

Unemployment last month hit a five-year high of 4.9 per cent while inflation in September was elevated at 4.3 per cent — a level well above the Reserve Bank’s 2-3 per cent target with economists expecting it to get even worse before it gets better.

Raising interest rates again risks pushing unemployment even higher and sparking a recession, with the five hikes so far this year taking the cash rate to an 18-year high of 4.85 per cent.

Sign up to The Nightly's newsletters.

Get the first look at the digital newspaper, curated daily stories and breaking headlines delivered to your inbox.

Email Us
By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.

Independent economist Saul Eslake has suggested the 12 per cent compulsory employer superannuation rate could be raised to a maximum of 13 per cent, in 25 basis point increments, as a way of reducing the take-home pay of Australian workers during a time of heightened inflation.

“That would affect a much bigger share of the population, basically everyone who has a job,” he told The Nightly.

He argued this would be fairer than inflicting pain on just the one in four Australian households with a mortgage.

“It would be in proportion to your income, because it’s a percentage of your income, so arguably would be fairer,” Mr Eslake said.

Under his proposal, an average, full-time worker earning $108,352 would have $1083 less in their bank, should compulsory super contributions temporarily be raised from 12 per cent to 13 per cent, as that money instead went towards their retirement savings.

By comparison, the RBA’s five interest rate hikes so far this year have raised monthly repayments by $601 on an average new mortgage of $736,000 — adding up to $7212 over a year.

New legislation would have to be passed giving the Reserve Bank of Australia’s monetary policy board the power to make a decision on whether to increase compulsory employer super contributions, along with deciding whether or not to raise or cut interest rates.

Economist Saul Eslake argues increasing super contributions would be fairer than inflicting pain on just one in four Australian households with a mortgage.
Economist Saul Eslake argues increasing super contributions would be fairer than inflicting pain on just one in four Australian households with a mortgage. Credit: Jackson Flindell/The West Australian

But during an economic slowdown, the RBA would also have the power to reduce the super guarantee contribution down to 11 per cent, also in 25 basis point increments, which would add $1083 to the bank accounts of the average worker, before tax.

“Additionally, you could say to people, ‘You mightn’t like this very much but it’s still your money; you will get it back, presumably plus a return when you retire’ or if at some point in the future, we have to lower the SGC rate, because the economy has weakened, and unemployment is rising, so you could use it in both directions,” Mr Eslake said.

The Reserve Bank of Australia has been in existence since 1960 with the Commonwealth Bank previously deciding interest rates as a government-owned financial institution with a separate monetary policy function.

But central bank rate hikes didn’t become the key instrument for tackling inflation until Nobel Prize-winning economist Milton Friedman’s theory on monetarism took hold during the late 1970s, blaming excessive money supply for the stagflation crisis where inflation and unemployment were both simultaneously at elevated levels following the OPEC oil crisis.

This has given Treasurer Jim Chalmers the cover to blame the RBA, whose independence was formalised in 1996, for unpopular rate hikes.

“It also became very politically convenient for governments to say when the central bank puts interest rates up, ‘I feel your pain but don’t blame me, it’s the independent central bank’ and Jim Chalmers is a master of that,” Mr Eslake said.

Previously, governments temporarily raised taxes during times of high inflation.

Australia’s inflation rate hit an all-time high of 23.9 per cent in December 1951 during the Korean War wool boom.

The Coalition government, then led by Liberal prime minister Robert Menzies, responded by introducing a 10 per cent surcharge on company and income tax and increasing wholesale sales taxes from 8.5 per cent to 12.5 per cent.

By the September quarter of 1954, inflation fell to zero, less than four years after inflation had hit double-digit figures.

That was four decades before Australia had formalised inflation targeting.

In the four years since Labor has been in power, inflation has only been within target for one year from July 2024 to August 2025, despite the RBA hiking interest rates 17 times during that period covering the Ukraine and Iran wars.

The chief economists of AMP and HSBC, Shane Oliver and Paul Bloxham, have warned the RBA’s aggressive interest rate hikes in an era of unaffordable housing are increasing the risk of a recession.

Australia last had an interest rate-rise induced recession in 1991 but the risks of history repeating 36 years later are growing, unless alternatives to a blunt economic instrument are explored.

Comments

Latest Edition

The Nightly cover for 19-11-2026

Latest Edition

Edition Edition 19 November 202619 November 2026

Pat Cummins’ captaincy under a cloud after Cam Bancroft’s explosive tell-all sends shockwaves through Aussie cricket.