opinion

EDITORIAL: Labor’s gas reservation plan is not in the national interest

EDITORIAL: The Federal gas reservation policy is at risk of delivering a scheme which results in significant unintended consequences.

The Nightly
“Less investment today means less gas tomorrow”.
“Less investment today means less gas tomorrow”. Credit: AAP

The need to ensure Australia has a long-term, reliable and affordable supply of gas is crucial.

That much is clear and certain.

But it is far from certain that the Albanese Government has devised a way for us to get there.

Sign up to The Nightly's newsletters.

Get the first look at the digital newspaper, curated daily stories and breaking headlines delivered to your inbox.

Email Us
By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.

Its proposed domestic gas reservation scheme is flawed.

The plan would require exporters to reserve 20 per cent of gas for domestic use and maintain a further 10 per cent as an oversupply buffer.

Ryan Stokes, chair of Beach Energy and Seven Media Group, which owns The Nightly, warned against the plan last week.

“We invest in gas supply through SGH Energy and Beach, and through Boral we are one of the country’s larger industrial gas users,” he said.

Reservation did not create “one more molecule of gas, and it risks less investment and less supply”.

“As drafted, the scheme undermines domestic gas producers by forcing exporters to sell against them.

“Oversupply may deliver a short-term sugar hit for buyers, but it pushes down the prices producers need to justify drilling new wells.

“Less investment today means less gas tomorrow, and that brings the very price spikes the Bill is meant to prevent.

Ryan Stokes at the Beach Energy annual general meeting in Adelaide on Wednesday Picture: Unknown
Ryan Stokes at the Beach Energy annual general meeting in Adelaide on Wednesday Unknown Credit: Unknown/Supplied

“The long-term consequences would decimate the domestic gas sector and the jobs that go with it, only to give short-term pricing power to multinational and foreign-owned wholesale users.

“The only way to get more gas to market is to encourage investment, not mandate sales,” Mr Stokes said.

His concerns were echoed at the weekend by Australian Energy Producers, which said new independent analysis showed the scheme could undermine investment in new supply, reduce competition and ultimately put upward pressure on energy prices.

The AEP said the Wood Mackenzie modelling reinforced Australian gas producers’ concerns with the scheme’s proposed “must-sell” and “10 per cent oversupply” requirements.

“These provisions could force exporters to sell gas into an already well-supplied market at below cost or on non-commercial terms and crowd out smaller domestic-focused producers that currently supply the majority of gas delivered to the east coast market,” the AEP said.

“The analysis finds that the proposed scheme does not meet its own objectives.

“Instead, it will undermine energy security, exacerbate the risk of shortfalls, and ultimately put upward pressure on gas prices for Australian households and businesses.

“Australia needs reliable gas supply, not another market intervention that makes it harder to invest,” AEP chief executive Samantha McCulloch said.

The contentious policy has also sparked debate about carving out Western Australia from the scheme — allowing the State’s longstanding 15 per cent reservation policy to remain.

WA would be well advised to remain extremely wary about the Federal plan.

Despite WA Premier Roger Cook’s claims on Tuesday of a last-minute victory to shield the State’s energy sector from Federal intervention, the Federal Energy Minister Chris Bowen would retain discretionary power over changes to the State’s gas requirements.

All of which indicates the Federal gas reservation policy is at risk of delivering significant unintended consequences far removed from the national interest. That would be representative of much of the Albanese Government’s flawed policies.

Responsibility for this editorial comment is taken by Editor-in-Chief Christopher Dore

Comments

Latest Edition

The Nightly cover for 18-11-2026

Latest Edition

Edition Edition 18 November 202618 November 2026

Not just for nerds: Game launch set to be a productivity-killing, internet-breaking cultural phenomenon.