Animal activist Emma Smart kills crayfish she ‘rescued’ from restaurant after throwing it in freezing water

An animal activist’s dramatic ‘rescue’ has backfired in spectacular fashion.

Troy de Ruyter
PerthNow
Sydney's new fish market in Glebe experiences its first major Easter trading period since opening in January, with 60,000 visitors expected on Good Friday alone.

An animal activist’s dramatic “rescue” has backfired in spectacular fashion — with the creature she tried to save likely killed the moment it hit the ocean.

Emma Smart stormed a Michelin-listed restaurant and grabbed what she thought was a lobster destined for the dinner plate.

But in a twist dripping with irony, the animal was actually a Mediterranean crayfish — a warm water species — that Smart hurled straight into freezing saltwater where it had little chance of survival.

Sign up to The Nightly's newsletters.

Get the first look at the digital newspaper, curated daily stories and breaking headlines delivered to your inbox.

Email Us
By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.
Animal activist Emma Smart.
Animal activist Emma Smart. Credit: Supplied

The crustacean had been kept for years by Catch at the Old Fish Market owner Anthony Cooper as an educational pet. With a tank mate, they were known as “Ronnie and Reggie”.

CCTV captured Smart charging into the venue, wrestling past staff and flinging the animal into Weymouth Harbour “like a cricket ball”.

Instead of saving it, the sudden shock of cold, salty water is believed to have killed it almost instantly.

Catch at the Old Fish Market owner Anthony Cooper.
Catch at the Old Fish Market owner Anthony Cooper. Credit: Supplied
Catch at the Old Fish Market in Weymouth.
Catch at the Old Fish Market in Weymouth. Credit: Supplied

Tragically, its companion later died too — possibly from stress or the loss of its longtime tank mate.

Smart admitted to criminal damage in court, telling the judge that she acted on impulse out of concern for animal welfare.

But the court was told that the crustacean was never intended for consumption — only for display and education.

Judge Susan Evans labelled the act “deeply misguided”, while Cooper said that he was left “deeply disappointed” by the outcome.

Emma Smart makes a run for it, with lobster in hand.
Emma Smart makes a run for it, with lobster in hand. Credit: Supplied

Originally published on PerthNow

Comments

Latest Edition

The Nightly cover for 16-04-2026

Latest Edition

Edition Edition 16 April 202616 April 2026

Aussies to be hit with further pain at the pump as refinery explosion torches oil crisis plan.