NEW YORK TIMES: Michael Jackson accusers say lawyer tricked them into signing hush-money deal

Five siblings who accused Michael Jackson of abusing them as children have now filed bombshell legal action.

Matt Stevens
The New York Times
Michael Jackson died in 2009.
Michael Jackson died in 2009. Credit: NELSON MACHIN/AP

Five members of the Cascio family who accused Michael Jackson this year of abusing them as children are now suing a lawyer who they say deceived them into signing a hush-money deal with the singer’s estate that they now regret.

In a 10-page complaint filed Wednesday in Los Angeles Superior Court, the Cascio family members, all siblings, accuse lawyer Bryan Freedman of malpractice, breach of fiduciary duty, fraud and negligent misrepresentation.

The Cascio siblings — Eddie, Dominic, Marie Nicole, Aldo and Frank — were longtime family friends and close confidants of Jackson who came forward after his death in 2009 to rebut claims by others that he had molested children. But several years ago, they said they, too, had been abused and had signed an agreement with the Jackson estate that provided them with monetary compensation through 2024.

Sign up to The Nightly's newsletters.

Get the first look at the digital newspaper, curated daily stories and breaking headlines delivered to your inbox.

Email Us
By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.

This year, after that agreement lapsed and negotiations for additional payments failed, the Cascios sued the estate and detailed their allegations of abuse in court papers, seeking damages.

The Cascio siblings, Eddie, Dominic, Aldo and Marie-Nicole, claim they were subjected to years of manipulation and abuse
The Cascio siblings, Eddie, Dominic, Aldo and Marie-Nicole, claim they were subjected to years of manipulation and abuse Credit: The Cascio siblings, Eddie, Dominic, Aldo and Marie-Nicole, claim they were subjected to years of manipulation and abuse

The lawsuit stalled, though, because language in the earlier agreement said that disputes between the parties would be resolved through arbitration, not civil litigation.

While the arbitration is proceeding, the Cascios are now suing Freedman who, the court papers say, was enlisted by the Jackson estate “to deceive Plaintiffs into signing” the agreement.

The suit says the agreement “stripped them of valuable legal rights, imposed sweeping confidentiality provisions, and shielded Jackson’s estate and representatives from liability.”

Paris Jackson, 28-year-old daughter of Michael Jackson, has filed a lawsuit seeking access to $860 million from her late father's estate.

The Cascios, who were not represented by a lawyer during the earlier negotiations, say Freedman never disclosed that the agreement would prohibit them from publicly discussing Jackson’s abuse. Instead, he convinced them “that he was advocating for their interests,” according to the court papers. Had he made the proper disclosures, the siblings say in court papers, they never would have signed the agreement, which has paid them roughly $16 million.

Freedman, a high-profile lawyer who also represented actor Justin Baldoni in his dispute with actor Blake Lively, did not respond to requests for comment.

The Jackson estate has consistently maintained Jackson’s denial that he ever molested children. Marty Singer, a lawyer for the estate, has characterized the siblings’ previous lawsuit as “a desperate money grab.”

Some of the siblings have said they did not recognize that what happened to them was abusive until they watched a 2019 documentary containing allegations by two men who said Jackson had molested them. Discussions about possible compensation for the Cascios began at that point and ended when the parties reached the agreement.

In their court papers filed Wednesday, the siblings say “Freedman never explained to Plaintiffs the implications of the Agreement’s complicated legalese” including the provisions about confidentiality and the fact that disputes would be settled through mandatory arbitration.

The Cascio siblings, from left: Dominic, Aldo, Marie Nicole and Eddie.
The Cascio siblings, from left: Dominic, Aldo, Marie Nicole and Eddie. Credit: THE NEW YORK TIMES/NYT

Instead, the lawsuit says, Freedman “assured Plaintiffs that he was advocating for their interests and dissuaded them from retaining independent counsel, while concealing that he was acting exclusively on behalf of the Estate and had a direct conflict of interest.”

But as the payments from the 2020 agreement were nearing their end in 2024, according to court papers, Freedman told siblings that the estate was willing to make additional payments. The siblings say Freedman also argued that the previous agreement had been insufficient.

“Freedman finally told Plaintiffs that they needed an attorney” and “tried to convince them to hire him to negotiate with the Estate,” the court papers say.

“Freedman’s conflict of interest became obvious,” and the siblings retained independent counsel, the court papers say.

Originally published on The New York Times

Latest Edition

The Nightly cover for 19-11-2026

Latest Edition

Edition Edition 19 November 202619 November 2026

Pat Cummins’ captaincy under a cloud after Cam Bancroft’s explosive tell-all sends shockwaves through Aussie cricket.