opinion

MARK ‘SPUDD’ CARROLL: Kiwis lack the self-belief to beat the Kangaroos when it matters

MARK ‘SPUDD’ CARROLL: New Zealand’s resistance, fight and passion began and ended with the haka as the World Cup ended the way it always does – with a resounding win to Australia.

Mark ‘Spudd’ Carroll
The Nightly
The Kiwis simply don’t have the self-belief to get the job done against the Kangaroos when it matters.
The Kiwis simply don’t have the self-belief to get the job done against the Kangaroos when it matters. Credit: Bradley Kanaris/Getty Images

New Zealand’s resistance, fight and passion began and ended with the haka as the World Cup ended the way it always does – with a resounding win to Australia.

And the result might just re-shape international rugby league in a way the authorities didn’t intend.

I will get to that in a moment.

Sign up to The Nightly's newsletters.

Get the first look at the digital newspaper, curated daily stories and breaking headlines delivered to your inbox.

Email Us
By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.

The Kiwis simply don’t have the self-belief to get the job done against the Kangaroos when it matters.

It’s like when the Wallabies meet the All Blacks – both sides know who’s going to win as they walk out.

Mentality over-rides performance.

Yes, Kevin Walters’ team was magnificent and congratulations to them on a superb campaign.

Please, take a bow.

They got better with each game and showed that passion and commitment for the jersey is not just confined to the Pasifika nations and New Zealand.

The World Cup was so-so for mine as far as quality games go and I think the final again underlined the gulf between Australia and the rest.

The Roos have now won 23 World Cup games straight.

We kept hearing how Samoa, Tonga and the Kiwis were coming to slay the dragon, but they produced butter knives instead of swords.

New Zealand talked the talk but couldn’t walk the walk.

Their embarrassing performance at Suncorp was stage-fright on an industrial scale.

Right from the moment winger Jamayne Isaako booted the ball dead from the kick-off, you could tell their game heads weren’t screwed on.

They conceded a try off the back of that mistake and then made just about every error you could possibly fit into 80 minutes of rugby league.

And the Kangaroos made them pay dearly at every turn.

So why might this result change the way things are at the next World Cup?

Well, with Australia continuing to dominate, will players be as eager to switch nations before the next tournament in 2030?

I don’t think so.

Tino Faasuamaleaui copped it for opting to play for Australia over Samoa, with some fans booing his every touch in last weekend’s semi-final.

I found that a bit ordinary seeing we applaud Australian-born players who go the other way and choose to represent their family heritage and culture by playing for their parents’ or grandparents’ homelands.

Don’t get me wrong, I have absolutely no problem if players go down that road.

It’s been a wonderful boost for the international game to see the emergence of Tonga, Samoa and, to a lesser extent, Fiji on the world stage.

But Australia reminding everyone who’s boss at this World Cup might just cause a shift in thinking as players decide who they will represent in the future.

AND DON’T GET ME STARTED

If South Sydney land Sam Walker, you can install them as premiership favourites for next season.

With Payne Haas already at the club, Walker’s arrival would be the final piece in Wayne Bennett’s jigsaw puzzle.

Throw in one of the game’s best halfbacks alongside a world class prop and it’s a potent mix.

The Rabbitohs have been churning through No.7s since Adam Reynolds was let go and have been unable to nail down a settled halves combination.

Critics will say Walker’s off-the-cuff style is too similar to Cody Walker’s, but I believe Bennett could devise a system that would bring the best out in both of them.

And big Payne will give them the perfect platform to create their magic.

Of course, Sam Walker’s move down the road will only happen if the Roosters green light it.

And when I say Roosters, I really mean chairman Nick Politis.

There is no love lost between Souths and the Roosters and Politis will hate giving his arch-rivals a huge leg up.

But he’s a businessman first and will do the deal that best suits his club.

The latest whisper is Walker may earn a reprieve and stay at Bondi next year before joining the Chiefs in 2028.

That would take a back down from Politis – something he is not normally inclined to do.

The Bunnies will be desperately hoping the Roosters boss sticks to his guns and shows the kid the door.

BEFORE I GO

That’s the fulltime siren you can hear on my column for the year as another season of rugby league officially ends.

I’ve loved every minute of bringing my views to The Nightly’s readership every Monday.

You may not have agreed with everything I wrote, but hopefully you walked away entertained and a little bit more informed about this crazy game we all love so passionately.

Thank-you for reading each week and thanks also to the editorial staff at The Nightly for their support.

Enjoy your off-season and the Christmas break and we’ll see you in 2027.

Comments

Latest Edition

The Nightly cover for 16-11-2026

Latest Edition

Edition Edition 16 November 202616 November 2026

Insider’s Sir Les sledge reveals party angst towards gaffe-prone PM.