Joseph Gerard Cancellare: Man arrested over allegedly lacing mail with peanut butter to cause allergy attack

A man who is alleged to have covered a letter with peanut butter, and sent it to a woman ‘deathly allergic’ to peanuts, has been arrested.

Anna Beisser
The Nightly
Detectives determined that Joseph Gerard Cancellare Jr., 68, of Plantation, sent the envelope.
Detectives determined that Joseph Gerard Cancellare Jr., 68, of Plantation, sent the envelope. Credit: Plantation Police Department

A man who is alleged to have covered a letter with peanut butter and sent it to a woman “deathly allergic” to peanuts, has been arrested.

After an investigation spanning more than a year, Joseph Gerard Cancellare Jr. was arrested in Florida on November 13.

The Plantation Police Department said in a social media post on Monday that Mr Cancellare is facing charges of aggravated battery and culpable negligence.

Sign up to The Nightly's newsletters.

Get the first look at the digital newspaper, curated daily stories and breaking headlines delivered to your inbox.

Email Us
By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.

The incident occurred on August 14, 2025, when a woman whose name has been redacted received a card in her mailbox.

According to an arrest report, the victim emptied her mailbox to find a “blue envelope that appeared greasy with handwriting she did not recognise”.

The arrest report states she immediately recognised the presence of peanut butter in the greeting card.

Her exposure to the peanut butter on the card caused her to break out in an allergic reaction, despite immediately trying to remove the peanut butter from her hands.

Police said the woman developed “hives on both arms” and had “a tingling sensation in both arms that lasted 6 hours”.

The arrest report is redacted, but it states that Mr Cancellare’s divorce from the victim’s best friend was viewed as “contentious” and he “largely blamed [redacted] for the divorce.”

The victim said Mr Cancellare “would absolutely know about her allergy” as they knew each other personally.

The arrest report states he “made it well known in their friend group that he wished [redacted] harm.”

Investigations found Mr Cancellare was captured on camera purchasing the two stamps used on the envelope sent to the victim.

An official motive has not yet been released by investigators.

He was taken to the Broward County Jail, and the bond was set at $20,000 USD.

Comments

Latest Edition

The Nightly cover for 16-11-2026

Latest Edition

Edition Edition 16 November 202616 November 2026

Insider’s Sir Les sledge reveals party angst towards gaffe-prone PM.