analysis

Confused about the state of the economy? Inside the RBA’s board’s split decision to lift interest rates

AARON PATRICK: A record of the central bank’s meeting two weeks ago, when it raised rates, shows members grappling to interpret contradictory signals about the economy’s strength.

Headshot of Aaron Patrick
Aaron Patrick
The Nightly
Reserve Bank governor Michele Bullock, who has overseen five interest rate rises this year.
Reserve Bank governor Michele Bullock, who has overseen five interest rate rises this year. Credit: AAP

Even the Reserve Bank of Australia’s board wasn’t certain it should have raised interest rates two weeks ago.

Details of the discussion among board members, published today, reveal a vigorous debate over whether a fifth rate rise would be an unnecessarily aggressive step to kill off inflation.

One or more of the nine board members — the central bank never discloses names in the board’s minutes — pointed out unemployment had risen more than expected and the economy might be already returning to a calmer state.

Sign up to The Nightly's newsletters.

Get the first look at the digital newspaper, curated daily stories and breaking headlines delivered to your inbox.

Email Us
By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.

They were overruled. The board voted six-three to raise official rates to 4.85 per cent, a decision that caused significant financial pain to millions of Australians and not inconsequential political damage to the Albanese Government.

For anyone following the economic debate or trying to predict interest rates, the minutes may be both reassuring and worrying.

In a positive sense, they suggest the board’s independent members debated assertions put by Reserve Bank economists that the rules of economics have changed and rates will have to stay higher for longer than in the past.

On the down side, the minutes show that some of the nation’s best economists are uncertain about what is happening in the economy and are, in crude terms, making it up.

“I have never seen that much discussion about the risks to both sides of the decision,” said Diana Mousina, the AMP’s deputy chief economist.

Recession?

Despite RBA Governor Michele Bullock’s warning after the meeting there was too much demand in the economy — as businesses built more factories and opened new stores — the board members saw plenty examples of Australians in financial pain.

One case was particularly important. Some members thought falling property prices might trigger a sellers’ strike, which could hit demand for washing machines, stoves, plumbers and carpenters as the number of post-purchase renovations fell.

One of the out-voted board members was recorded stating: “The economy might be near the point of entering a materially sharper downturn and pointed to the costs in terms of unemployment.”

This warning sounded like it came from someone thinking the word “recession”.

Grappling with contradictory signals, the majority decided it was safer to try to slay inflation than hope growth would slow under the weight of four previous rises.

Which suggests the Reserve Bank, feeling chastised over last year’s premature rate cuts, has decided fighting rising prices is more important than avoiding an inadvertent recession.

That is unpleasant news for millions of borrowers and Treasurer Jim Chalmers, whose departmental secretary Jenny Wilkinson is assumed by some economists to be among the three dissenters.

Economists believe Treasury secretary Jenny Wilkinson was one of the three Reserve Bank board members who opposed this month’s interest rate rise.
Economists believe Treasury secretary Jenny Wilkinson was one of the three Reserve Bank board members who opposed this month’s interest rate rise. Credit: NCA NewsWire

Blame game

On Tuesday Dr Chalmers again suggested higher interest rates were caused by foreign developments, including the war over Iran, the artificial intelligence boom and US share market falls.

“Australians feel all this through portfolio values, mortgage repayments and high fuel prices,” he said in Sydney. “These global pressures are making the inflation challenge we were dealing with before the war much worse.”

In the past, Ms Bullock has tried to avoid appearing to contradict Dr Chalmers over the primary causes of inflation. That’s because many credible economists say the Federal Budget deficit is fuelling higher prices, forcing the Reserve Bank to raise rates higher than it otherwise would.

Today, speaking after the Treasurer at the same event, Ms Bullock chose to explicitly identify inflation as home-grown problem.

“One thing I wanted to make extremely clear, it is not just a response to oil prices, we already had inflation above target in the latter half of last year and early this year and we were already lifting interest rates before the Middle East war,” she said.

Today, Ms Bullock did not say foreign events have had no impact on the economy. She mentioned the pandemic, the invasion of Ukraine, US trade tariffs, climate change and the jump in oil prices caused by America’s war with Iran.

In the minutes of the Reserve Bank meeting held over November 2 and 3, though, only one of these five tumultuous events was mentioned other than in passing. That was the global oil shock.

The Reserve Bank’s experts calculated two thirds of higher oil prices would flow through to inflation, embedding the perception among Australians prices would continue to rise more than 3 per cent, year after year.

There was an important qualification. The experts predicted oil prices would fall about $US30 ($43) a barrel over the following two years, a prediction the board questioned.

“Members noted that, for this assumption to be valid, there would need to be some degree of resolution of the conflict,” the minutes stated.

Since then, Donald Trump has declared the war “effectively over”, spot oil prices have fallen $US17-to-$US20 a barrel and Australian petrol prices are lower than they were in March.

Which shows the perils of predicting the future, even for people paid to do it.

Comments

Latest Edition

The Nightly cover for 16-11-2026

Latest Edition

Edition Edition 16 November 202616 November 2026

Insider’s Sir Les sledge reveals party angst towards gaffe-prone PM.