opinion

Jim Chalmers’ changes will allow superannuation to be invested in subsidised housing, wind and solar farms

Jim Chalmers is plotting to make it easier for super funds to invest in government priorities, while loosening rules around investors being told of poor decisions, Aaron Patrick reports.

Headshot of Aaron Patrick
Aaron Patrick
The Nightly
Australians withdrew over $1 billion from their superannuation before retirement to cover medical costs in the last financial year, according to ATO data.

Treasurer Jim Chalmers has talked about using Australians’ retirement savings for “national priorities” almost since the day the Labor Party won power in 2022.

Now he is about to make a move, forcing ordinary Australians to underwrite his ambitions.

On Wednesday Dr Chalmers plans to announce changes to superannuation regulation. The industry expects him to loosen rules designed to warn people when the managers of their investments make poor decisions.

Sign up to The Nightly's newsletters.

Get the first look at the digital newspaper, curated daily stories and breaking headlines delivered to your inbox.

Email Us
By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.

The changes would make it easier for super funds to invest in subsidised housing and wind and solar farms, two of Dr Chalmers’ preferred industries. Without that money, the government looks to have almost no chance of meeting its climate or housing targets.

Even though most super savings are controlled by funds associated with unions and the Labor Party, Dr Chalmers can’t direct them to go out and spend $100 billion supporting government policy.

Super funds are legally required to act in investors’ best interests, a foundation of the system that senior politicians and vested business interests want to undermine.

They may have succeeded. Australian Financial Review reporter Lucas Baird reported today — reporting backed up by industry sources — that Dr Chalmers plans to introduce a cunning rules change that almost no-one outside the industry will understand.

At the moment, most union-associated super funds are subjected to a walk-of-shame system known as the APRA annual performance test. If they do a bad job managing money, they have to confess in a letter. If they stuff up twice in a row, they have to advise their investors to dump them.

Superannuation Funds Faults
llustration: Don Lindsay
Superannuation Funds Faults llustration: Don Lindsay Credit: Don Lindsay/The West Australian

The system is a brutal and effective way of communicating with millions of people who barely know what a superannuation account is, let alone what’s a reasonable return.

What are known as industry super funds dislike it. The third pillar of the broader labour movement alongside unions and the Labor Party, they have been lobbying Dr Chalmers for years for relief from the unwelcome scrutiny.

It looks like they have got some of what they want. Dr Chalmers reportedly will exempt 5 per cent of funds’ investments from the test.

That may not sound a lot, but APRA-regulated super funds contain some $3.4 trillion. So that’s $170 billion that would be subject to lower thresholds tied to inflation.

Superannuation savers might ask: “What’s wrong with that? I believe there is good money to be made from renewable energy. I like ethical investments.”

Treasurer Jim Chalmers' economic management has been in the spotlight in recent weeks.
Treasurer Jim Chalmers' economic management has been in the spotlight in recent weeks. Credit: AAP

If individuals want to apply personal values to investing, that’s great. But history shows the heart does not provide a path to prosperity.

On the Australian share market, the S&P/ASX 200 ESG fund tracks the performance of “sustainable” companies. In the six years of the fund’s existence, it has risen 7 per cent. The S&P/ASX 200 index, which includes gas producers, rose 48 per cent over the same period.

One of the dangers of looser rules is the prospect it could lead to political influence over funds’ investments.

Dr Chalmers is open about his belief retirement savings could fund “nation-building” investments in renewable energy and housing. In a 2023 interview with the Financial Times he framed using private capital to pursue the government’s goals as “values-based capitalism”.

The network

The biggest industry fund, AustralianSuper, has been a leading advocate of looser rules. Fund chairman Don Russell has a long and prosperous career as a Labor-associated bureaucrat and ministerial adviser. Deputy chair Michele O’Neil is president of the Australian Council of Trade Unions.

They sit atop a network of union officials who have secured sinecures on superannuation boards.

One of the worst examples might be BUSSQ, which mostly invests on behalf of Queensland construction workers. BUSSQ operates the only MySuper fund (a common low-risk, low-fee option) that failed the APRA performance test this year.

The BUSSQ board includes three employees of the CFMEU’s construction division, which is being investigated by a royal commission-like inquiry run by barrister Stuart Wood KC.

Then there is the lure of celebrity founders. An intellectual leader of the renewable energy industry, economist Ross Garnaut co-founded ZEN Energy, which traded solar power in South Australia. Dr Garnaut’s books arguing Australia could be an “economic superpower of the future post-carbon world” by taxing Greenhouse gas emissions were influential across the labour movement.

Unfortunately for investors who shared Dr Garnaut’s vision, ZEN Energy went broke in July owing about $1.1 billion.

Other technology heavily subsidised by government that has failed to make any significant economic contribution includes hydrogen energy and quantum computing.

Perhaps the worst “renewable” investment in Australia’s history is a series of dams in the Snowy Mountains dubbed Snowy 2.0. Promoted by its instigator, then-Liberal prime minister Malcolm Turnbull as a $2 billion project to generate hydro-electricity on demand, it has morphed into a $20b-plus monster that some experts think should be abandoned.

Snowy 2.0, ZEN Energy and the many failed hydrogen schemes are a warning that while “nation building” sounds great in speeches and newspaper interviews, it rarely delivers returns for investors.

Maybe Dr Chalmers should leave superannuants to invest how they choose. After all, it is their money, not his.

Comments

Latest Edition

The Nightly cover for 16-11-2026

Latest Edition

Edition Edition 16 November 202616 November 2026

Insider’s Sir Les sledge reveals party angst towards gaffe-prone PM.