opinion

BEN HARVEY: Why Pat Cummins’ Sandpapergate claim is bull

Actual cricket — as bowling, hitting or throwing the ball — accounts for maybe 20 per cent of the time on field. You know what the fielding side does with the other 80 per cent? Inspect the ball. 

Headshot of Ben Harvey
Ben Harvey
The Nightly
Pat Cummins and Cam Bancroft.
Pat Cummins and Cam Bancroft. Credit: AAP/TheWest

I loved playing cricket when I was a kid.

I’m not sure my parents loved the fact I loved it because for many years they had to spend hour after (in Dad’s case, hungover) hour watching me from the boundary every weekend between October and March.

A parent’s love for a child can be tested in many ways and sitting in the sun on a 40C day as a bunch of confused kids try to play one of the world’s most complicated sports is certainly one of them.

Sign up to The Nightly's newsletters.

Get the first look at the digital newspaper, curated daily stories and breaking headlines delivered to your inbox.

Email Us
By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.

As a leg spin bowler (well before Shane Warne made it cool, I might add) I was always concentrating on the condition of the pitch rather than the ball.

Spinners are always searching for a patch of rough they can aim at because they know the rotating Kookaburra will grip there better than on smooth grassy sections.

Get it right and the ball will slingshot off the deck in ways that befuddle the batter.

Fast bowlers, particularly those who know how to swing the ball, are also fixated on rough and smooth.

Just not on the pitch.

Champion swing bowlers like Wasim Akram, Waqar Younis and (dare I say the name) Richard Hadlee get the ball to move in the air by shining one half so the air moves across that portion of the leather differently to the other side.

Bowlers treat that glossy side like it’s the most delicate and precious thing on earth so the shine remains pristine.

And they treat the other half like a red-headed stepchild so it deteriorates and becomes rough. Physics dictates that the bigger the surface differential, the bigger the swing.

Billions of children who watched the world’s great bowlers shining the ball methodically as they walked back to their marks have taken great pride in coming home with a deep red stain on their whites.

Those same kids quickly came to learn that if you added a little spit or sweat before you started rubbing the ball the shine would be more pronounced.

Smarter kids realised that sweaty sunscreen and spit conjured while you had a boiled lolly in your mouth was even more effective.

And if you dragged your fingernails across the dull side? Or ground it into a rough part of the wicket? Even better.

And thus begins the passive descent into the kind of ball tampering that Cameron Bancroft says is institutionalised.

Here’s the rub (sorry): there’s a difference between passively neglecting one side of the ball and actively roughing it up.

You aren’t allowed to sabotage the ball. But everyone does it. In that third test in Cape Town eight years ago, Bancroft just did it more obviously than others.

I don’t know if everyone knew he had busted out the Powerpass and loaded up on 80 grit at Bunnings but they sure as hell knew the ball’s appearance was suspiciously and conspicuously changing during.

You need to remember test cricket is a very, very slow game. How many summer sports are there in the world where the athletes wear jumpers?

There’s so much down time the commentators channel David Attenborough to fill the dead air. How many times have you heard the person behind the microphone talking about seagulls on the field?

Players at long on or fine leg do callisthenics to avoid deep vein thrombosis. Who can forget Bay 13 at the MCG stretching in time to Merv Hughes?

Actual cricket — as in the acts of bowling, hitting or throwing the ball — accounts for maybe 20 per cent of the time on field.

You know what the fielding side does with the other 80 per cent? Inspect the ball.

A six stitcher in test cricket gets paid more attention than any other ball in any other ball sport.

The idea that all 11 Australians on the field on March 24, 2018, didn’t know that one half of the Kookaburra was very quickly starting to look like it had been in a car crash is ridiculous.

Pat Cummins used a press conference that went for so long the journos got bed sores to stress he was none the wiser. He said Usman Khawaja was wrong to say the whole team knew what Bancroft was up to.

It wasn’t going to take much to take the, errr, shine off Khawaja’s standing as a courageous whistleblower and Cummins’ emphatic denial did the job.

Some of us already had doubts about his motives. How is it that a bloke principled enough to stare down the ICC over Gaza lost his moral compass when he was in the change room watching a teammate put sandpaper in his pocket?

Those doubters surely had pause for thought after reading Bancroft’s warts-and-all account of what really happened.

We cheated.

It’s an ugly chapter in Australian sport but good news for Trevor Chappell. It’s taken 45 years, but something might finally overtake his underarm delivery as the most unsportsmanlike act in Australian cricket.

Comments

Latest Edition

The Nightly cover for 19-11-2026

Latest Edition

Edition Edition 19 November 202619 November 2026

Pat Cummins’ captaincy under a cloud after Cam Bancroft’s explosive tell-all sends shockwaves through Aussie cricket.