opinion

LORRAINE FINLAY: Victorian election AI deepfakes a threat to democratic integrity

LORRAINE FINLAY: How can voters be expected to judge a party or candidate when they can no longer trust their own eyes and ears?

Lorraine Finlay
The Nightly
An AI-generated image posted to the Victoria Liberals' Facebook page shows Premier Ben Carroll napping on the job.
An AI-generated image posted to the Victoria Liberals' Facebook page shows Premier Ben Carroll napping on the job. Credit: Facebook

The Victorian election campaign is raising a question that reaches well beyond party politics: what happens to democracy when we cannot trust what we see and hear?

Reports of deepfake content appearing during the Victorian election campaign raise serious questions about the continuing integrity of democratic debate in Australia.

Trust is one of the foundations of any healthy democracy. We need to trust elections, public institutions and the information we use to make decisions. Voters should be able to judge people on what they actually say and do, not on a version of them manufactured by their opponents.

Sign up to The Nightly's newsletters.

Get the first look at the digital newspaper, curated daily stories and breaking headlines delivered to your inbox.

Email Us
By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.

AI-generated content, also called synthetic media, includes images, videos and recordings created or altered using AI. Deepfakes depict real people saying or doing things they never actually said or did.

AI can have enormous benefits, helping us learn, create, communicate and access information more easily. The problem is not simply that AI has been used. It is whether the resulting content misleads people or causes harm.

When someone’s image or voice is used without their consent to create false content, the consequences can be devastating. People can be humiliated, harassed, intimidated or falsely portrayed in ways that damage their relationships, careers and sense of safety. Deepfake sexual abuse material shows just how serious those harms can be.

Women, LGBTIQA+ people and multicultural communities are often disproportionately targeted. Synthetic content frequently amplifies existing prejudice, reinforcing racism, misogyny and bigotry.

These harms to individuals also affect the health of our democracy. When people are harassed or humiliated, the impact extends beyond the individual who is targeted. It can create a chilling effect that discourages open discussion and made public participation feel less safe.

People may simply decide that it is safer not to participate. They stop speaking up online, at work, at school or socially. Their voices disappear from conversations that affect everyone.

An AI-generated video created by Victorian Labor showed Liberal leader Jess Wilson and One Nation's Warren Pickering appearing to promise an Americanised healthcare system.
An AI-generated video created by Victorian Labor showed Liberal leader Jess Wilson and One Nation's Warren Pickering appearing to promise an Americanised healthcare system. Credit: Instagram

But the risks extend beyond those who are directly targeted. An election deepfake does not have to fool every voter to cause harm. The deeper challenge is the erosion of trust itself.

People may be persuaded that events occurred when they didn’t. They may also dismiss genuine information as fake. Even those who recognise a fabrication may become less certain about the next video they see.

This affects all of us because our democracy relies on a shared understanding of reality. We do not all need to agree on every political issue, but we do need some shared understanding of basic facts.

That is becoming harder in an online environment shaped by algorithms designed for maximum engagement.

Social media is a part of daily life for most people in Australia. The content in our social media feeds is increasingly selected by systems that prioritise attention, outrage and virality. We are often shown material that reinforces our existing views, regardless of whether it is accurate.

In these echo chambers, synthetic media can spread quickly, feeding conspiracy theories, sowing division and destroying trust in public institutions and electoral processes.

The danger is not only that people might believe false information. It is that people stop believing anything at all.

The examples from the Victorian election campaign should be a sign to act, not another warning we walk past. The issue is not which political party is affected by a particular fabrication. It is whether all Australians can continue to make informed choices based on information they can trust.

Yet there is no single solution.

Our new report, Breaking Trust, calls for a co-ordinated response involving governments, technology companies, educators, media organisations and civil society.

Laws must keep pace with rapidly evolving technology. Electoral protections should be targeted and politically neutral, addressing deceptive content while protecting legitimate satire, commentary and freedom of expression. Protecting democracy must not become a reason to silence the debate it depends on.

Practical measures such as content labelling, authenticity standards and stronger digital literacy programs can help people assess what they encounter online. But labels can be removed and detection is imperfect. No single tool will be effective alone.

Independent journalism, trusted public institutions, and civic education also have an essential role to play. People need reliable sources of information, not just more reasons to doubt what appears in their feeds.

Most importantly, we cannot afford to wait until public trust has been seriously damaged before acting.

The Victorian election campaign is a reminder that preserving trust is not a challenge for the future. It is a responsibility now.

We can enjoy the benefits of new technology while protecting what matters most: people’s dignity, democratic participation and a shared confidence in what is real. Voters should be choosing between competing visions for their future, not competing versions of reality.

Lorraine Finlay is the Australian Human Rights Commissioner

Comments

Latest Edition

The Nightly cover for 17-11-2026

Latest Edition

Edition Edition 17 November 202617 November 2026

Albanese abandons his d..k jokes and melon gags during awk-Quad reunion.