DVIR ABRAMOVICH: Hate preachers understand the law. That’s what makes them so dangerous

DVIR ABRAMOVICH: We think of the extremist as a person who has lost control. But the most insidious figures are disciplined and know precisely where the threshold into illegality lies.

Dvir Abramovich
The Nightly
A Federal Court judge found Wissam Haddad’s lectures contained “fundamentally racist and anti-Semitic” material.

There is a word that keeps coming up in Australia’s argument about hate preachers, and it is “threshold”.

Last week the Australian Federal Police Commissioner, Krissy Barrett, told The Australian that she had twice asked her officers to review the sermons of certain preachers to see if charges could be laid. Both times the sermons were “not reaching a threshold”.

Then she offered an explanation that deserves more attention than it has received.

Sign up to The Nightly's newsletters.

Get the first look at the digital newspaper, curated daily stories and breaking headlines delivered to your inbox.

Email Us
By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.

“I am convinced some hate preachers are getting legal advice to ensure they push it right to the edge to prevent the AFP from laying charges.”

I have spent a long time thinking about how hatred moves through a society, and I think that sentence describes something new.

We usually picture the extremist as a person who has lost control: the ranter, the zealot, the man who says too much.

The figure the Commissioner describes is the opposite. He is disciplined. He knows precisely where the threshold is, and he has arranged his life so as to stand just in front of it, every week, in full view, with an audience.

That changes the question we should be asking. It is not whether these men are dangerous. It is what kind of law can reach a person who has studied the law.

Ours, at present, cannot. After the Bondi massacre last December, the Government drafted a criminal offence of inciting racial hatred. It did not survive the negotiations in January. What passed instead were heavier penalties for religious leaders who urge or threaten violence.

Those penalties are serious, up to 12 years, and they rest on the assumption that the danger lies in the explicit call to arms. But the preacher who takes legal advice never makes the explicit call.

He can describe a people as treacherous or as the enemy, and leave his listeners to draw the conclusion. Our law forbids the act. He has learned to supply only the purpose.

A Federal Court judge found Wissam Haddad’s lectures contained “fundamentally racist and anti-Semitic” material. The civil case against Hassad was brought by the Executive Council of Australian Jewry.
A Federal Court judge found Wissam Haddad’s lectures contained “fundamentally racist and anti-Semitic” material. The civil case against Hassad was brought by the Executive Council of Australian Jewry. Credit: Nikki Short NewsWire/NCA NewsWire

The record is consistent. NSW Police examined a 2023 sermon in which a cleric called jihad “the solution” and found no offence. State and Federal police closed their investigations into Wissam Haddad’s lectures. So far as is publicly known, the only effective legal action against Haddad has been a civil case brought by the Executive Council of Australian Jewry, which persuaded the Federal Court that his lectures unlawfully vilified Jews. It is a strange arrangement, in a country built on equal protection, that the people being vilified must fund their own defence, and then pursue the costs through the bankruptcy courts.

Britain reached the same diagnosis five years ago. In 2021 Sara Khan and Sir Mark Rowley, later head of the Metropolitan Police, reviewed the law on what they called hateful extremism. They found that “many extremists are able to operate lawfully, freely, and with impunity”, and that it was lawful in Britain to stir up racial hatred deliberately “so long as one avoids being threatening, abusive or insulting”.

Their prime example was the preacher Anjem Choudary, who, they found, operated lawfully and freely for years. Their remedy was a new offence that looks at the speaker’s intent. Choudary was eventually caught another way, and is now serving life for directing a terrorist organisation.

Canada has gone further this year. Its Combating Hate Act, which took effect in July, repealed the old defence for statements made in good faith as religious opinion. Ottawa’s view was that freedom of religion is already protected by the constitution and does not need a special exemption in the criminal code.

That is precisely the question Australia flinched from in January, when its draft offence included a defence for quoting or referencing religious texts.

Krissy Barrett said she had twice asked her officers to review the sermons of certain preachers to see if charges could be laid.
Krissy Barrett said she had twice asked her officers to review the sermons of certain preachers to see if charges could be laid. Credit: John Appleyard NewsWire/NCA NewsWire

New Zealand offers the opposite lesson. After Christchurch, its royal commission recommended strengthening the law against hate speech, and the government accepted the recommendation. Then it diluted the proposal, and then dropped it altogether. Good intentions, it turns out, do not survive contact with a long and unhurried argument.

The strongest objection to a new law deserves a fair hearing. It goes like this: the gap is not really in the statute but in enforcement. Police lack the skills to read coded religious language, prosecutors are cautious, and a new offence will gather dust like the others.

NSW’s own incitement law had produced only two charges by the end of last year. There is truth in this.

After the Bondi massacre last December, the Government drafted a criminal offence of inciting racial hatred.
After the Bondi massacre last December, the Government drafted a criminal offence of inciting racial hatred. Credit: AAP

But the objection proves less than it seems. A detective cannot enforce an offence that does not exist, and the AFP Commissioner has now said the sermons are not reaching the threshold for the offences that exist.

The lesson from NSW is not that such laws fail. It is that they must be drafted well.

The anti-Semitism envoy, Jillian Segal, warned NSW that a test built on the “likely effect” of words on an audience is “utterly unworkable”, because it asks a court to predict a crowd.

A law that asks whether the speaker deliberately promoted hatred against people because of their race or religion asks something a court can answer.

Special Envoy to Combat Antisemitism in Australia, Jillian Segal warned changes to NSW racial incitement laws were ‘utterly unworkable’.
Special Envoy to Combat Antisemitism in Australia, Jillian Segal warned changes to NSW racial incitement laws were ‘utterly unworkable’. Credit: Martin Ollman NewsWire/NCA NewsWire

Drafted that way, a law protects everyone. It reaches the neo-nazi as surely as the cleric. It protects Muslim Australians as well as Jews; Muslim leaders asked in January for religion to be covered, even as they opposed the Bill. And it leaves alone the vast territory of fierce, offensive, legitimate argument about Israel, faith and politics that a free country must protect.

The Government says it will “continue to monitor”. The Opposition says that if there are gaps, they “clearly must be addressed”. The royal commission reports on December 18. There will never be a better moment for the two parties to do together what they failed to do in January.

The preachers have found the threshold. They stand in front of it every week.

It is time Parliament decided where it should be.

Dr Dvir Abramovich is chairman of the Anti-Defamation Commission

Comments

Latest Edition

The Nightly cover for 16-11-2026

Latest Edition

Edition Edition 16 November 202616 November 2026

Insider’s Sir Les sledge reveals party angst towards gaffe-prone PM.