Sandpaper saga: Where every 2018 player stands in ball-tampering scandal

Friendships have been frayed and legacies are on the brink of being tarnished. If they haven’t already. Here is what the ball-tampering saga has meant for every Australian player on the infamous tour.

Headshot of Jackson Barrett
Jackson Barrett
The Nightly
Former Australia captain Steve Smith is maintaining his silence over the latest sandpapergate allegations.

Bodyline. World Series. Sandpaper.

Three scandals that have all rocked Australian cricket to its core.

The Ashes have never been the same after Bodyline. England’s bowling tactics in the 1932 series threatened relationships between the two nations and caused a national furore.

Sign up to The Nightly's newsletters.

Get the first look at the digital newspaper, curated daily stories and breaking headlines delivered to your inbox.

Email Us
By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.

Cricket has never been the same after Kerry Packer’s World Series mission. It snapped cricket into traditionalists and innovators and piledrove the sport into the 20th, then the 21st century, whether it liked it or not.

The sandpaper saga could have more longevity than its two predecessors because of the way it has split one of Australia’s greatest teams down the middle. Friendships have been frayed and legacies are on the brink of being tarnished. If they haven’t already.

Eight years on, the cheating scandal from 2018 has come to the boil again, is spilling from the sport pages to the news pages and has played out like a reality TV drama no Real Housewives script-writer could concoct. England fans, watching and chortling from afar, would say it’s more like a soapie.

When Cameron Bancroft published his version of the events in Cape Town that changed his life, it went off like a quake at Bellerive Oval in Hobart, where Australia were playing a one-day international against England on Wednesday.

It sent broadcasters, a series of whom were on that 2018 Test series, scurrying for cover.

A string of players had already given accounts of what happened. Usman Khawaja claimed the entire squad was in on the plot in his autobiography Sabr, released earlier this month, and that was backed up by David Warner and Chadd Sayers.

Captain Pat Cummins then attempted to brush it all off in a remarkable 70-minute press conference that stopped the nation in Sydney last Friday.

But it was all blown out of the water by Bancroft’s retelling. The man who was caught stuffing sandpaper down his cricket whites lifted the lid in graphic detail and in his own words.

Here is what it has meant for every Australian player on the infamous tour.

Steve Smith

The captain on the South Africa tour was frog-marched through the airport in Cape Town and back to Australia, where he broke down crying in a press conference at Sydney Airport.

This time, as they probably should have done eight years ago, New South Wales and Australian officials have closed ranks on Smith.

The champion Australian batter left last month’s tour of South Africa and headed to his home in New York, skipping New South Wales’ most recent Sheffield Shield match.

He is now back and expected to play in their next match, which begins in Sydney on Sunday.

Reporters were banned from filming and even watching Smith from inside the facility as he prepared for that match at the Sydney Cricket Ground on Friday in a rare move for a domestic team session.

It is understood Smith is not eager to speak on the matter at all, but as a very senior member of the Blues side and the vice-captain of the Australian Test team, he will surely be compelled in coming weeks.

Custom at domestic matches is for the best performer from each side on the day to front the press, which is most often led by print reporters. You know a day has gone really bad when a coach gets rolled out for the waiting media.

If he doesn’t speak this week, the time will come where he has to during the Test summer.

SYDNEY, AUSTRALIA NewsWire Photos Friday, 20 November 2026. Australian cricketer Steve Smith pictured during a training session at the SCG amid renewed controversy surrounding the Sandpapergate scandal. Picture NewsWire / Monique Harmer Picture: Monique Harmer Newswire
SYDNEY, AUSTRALIA NewsWire Photos Friday, 20 November 2026. Australian cricketer Steve Smith pictured during a training session at the SCG amid renewed controversy surrounding the Sandpapergate scandal. Picture NewsWire / Monique Harmer Monique Harmer Newswire Credit: Monique Harmer Newswire/NCA NewsWire

David Warner

Warner was working on the ODI match in Hobart when Bancroft tossed his grenade. There were periods of long silence in the Fox Cricket broadcast in the minutes afterwards (you can only imagine the phones being passed from broadcaster to broadcaster in the box) and both Warner and Khawaja were conspicuously absent from the post-match show later in the evening.

The former Test opener, who was banned for a year for his role as the instigator of the sandpaper plot, had played his shots earlier in the day when the broadcaster cut from Todd Greenberg and David Boon’s press conference announcing the independent forum into the scandal, straight to Warner and Khawaja’s criticism of it.

Khawaja revealed after the release of the book he had a long-held pact with his childhood friend Warner to come clean on the group’s knowledge of the use of sandpaper.

Warner — who has a book deal of his own but no immediate plans to publish — followed Khawaja in with a series of explosive social media posts blasting Cricket Australia’s handling of the investigation, which he described as “botched” before claiming Cummins was the only one of the bowlers to be interviewed in the expeditious investigation. It has later emerged the Hazlewood, Starc and Lyon were spoken to as part of the probe.

Speaking to 7NEWS the day after Bancroft released his story in The West, Warner said he was supportive of him and was glad his old opening partner could get the weight off his chest.

Warner will continue with Fox Cricket this season, including their coverage of the Twenty20 series between Australia and England starting today.

He will then link up with Bancroft as teammates at Big Bash League side Sydney Thunder.

Cameron Bancroft

It was the story the world had been waiting to hear and is, to this point, by far the most graphic and definitive recollection of not only the Cape Town Test, but the one before it in Port Elizabeth.

The key revelations from the 4500-word account — perhaps the biggest newspaper exclusive in the sport’s history — were that Bancroft’s tampering with the ball using sandpaper happened on the field from South Africa’s batting innings in the second Test, that he spoke to the bowlers to get feedback on the effectiveness of what he was doing and that it was celebrated in group meetings.

He also revealed media manager Kate Hutchison was the only person inside the dressing room that spoke out against the ploy and that head coach Darren Lehmann and bowling mentor David Saker were also involved.

Bancroft described himself as a “permanent outsider” to the Australian team.

The classy right-hand opening batter has lived in what is effectively cricket’s purgatory. He has been among the leading run-makers in the Sheffield Shield in almost every season since returning from his nine-month ban but never given a return to Test level after playing two more Tests under Justin Langer in the 2019 Ashes series.

On Thursday — his 34th birthday — Bancroft said he felt “freed” by his revelations and confirmed he will contribute to CA’s forum.

In typically strong form, Bancroft will open the batting for WA again in their shield match against Tasmania at Optus Stadium, which starts on Monday.

Weight off: Cameron Bancroft is feeling lighter after making public his version of sandpapergate. (James Ross/AAP PHOTOS)
Weight off: Cameron Bancroft is feeling lighter after making public his version of sandpapergate. (James Ross/AAP PHOTOS) Credit: AAP

Peter Handscomb

The Victorian batter was a junior reserve on this tour of South Africa, having been picked for a debut, then dropped from the side in the years before it.

But as bleary-eyed Aussies snubbed sleep to watch the gripping Test in Cape Town eight years ago, Handscomb was one of the key characters on our screens.

When Lehmann called down to the dugout on the walkie-talkie, it was Handscomb on the other line.

“Peter Handscomb ran out at the drinks break after I’d been caught and shoved the sandpaper down my pants,” Bancroft wrote.

“He said to me: ‘I think it’s time I take that off you now’. And Pete was doing his job after Boof shouted to him on the walkie talkie ‘get the f***ing sandpaper off Bangers now’.

Handscomb is still playing for Victoria but is also building an impressive media career. He was working on the Hobart ODI for SEN when Bancroft’s story dropped and did not return to the air in the evening session. He also declined to comment to reporters at the venue.

Usman Khawaja

Khawaja dropped a bomb on Australian cricket and then buried his head in the sand.

It was the recently-retired opener who peeled back the surface in his highly-anticipated autobiography chapter on this Test.

But it all got big on him in the days afterwards. Khawaja was stumped on national TV by 7.30 Report host Sarah Ferguson when asked to expand on allegations against the bowlers.

He then wound back his rolling media tour of the country in the days to come, contributing to only a few podcasts and TV shows, many of which did not even broach the sandpaper topic.

Khawaja twice postponed an interview with popular podcast The Grade Cricketer. His rescheduled appearance on the program had been slated for Thursday, but was postponed indefinitely after Bancroft’s release. Co-host Sam Perry said on the episode the interview had been set-up on the basis it would promote the book in its entirety and that the program and Khawaja agreed that would have been disingenuous.

The 39-year-old is now embarking on his first full summer as a pundit in murky waters.

Shaun Marsh

The beloved former Australia and WA batter from the famous cricketing family has always kept out of the limelight on this issue.

During an interview in 2022, Marsh revealed he was not interviewed as part of the probe, but has never made any other comments on the matter.

“I wasn’t interviewed. I was a little bit surprised at the time. That’s all I’ll say,” Marsh said.

Approached by The West as recently as this week, Marsh — who is now retired from all forms of cricket — declined to comment.

Mitchell Marsh

The other Marsh brother hasn’t found it so easy to duck questioning.

Renowned as an old-fashioned knockabout cricketer, Marsh’s role as the captain of the Twenty20 team and the stand-in skipper of the 50-over team means he is constantly in front of press and broadcasters.

In his media conference before the series-opening ODI in Perth earlier this month, Marsh played an uncharacteristically dead bat to 21 questions about the scandal. He also did not answer questions when approached by 7NEWS at Melbourne Airport.

While team captains traditionally address the media before an international series, they are not obligated to do so. It means a decision over whether to speak or not as Australia play five 20-over matches across the next fortnight will be up to Marsh.

But he will come under mounting pressure to address his friend and State teammate Bancroft’s claims.

Marsh was bowling at the time Bancroft was caught with sandpaper and in a period where Australia took 4-28 with reverse swing a feature in the Test prior.

He bowled 21 overs across those two matches, but was not a signatory to the bowlers’ statement denying knowledge of sandpaper being used on the field.

Tim Paine

The Tasmanian had only just been parachuted from obscurity back into the Test side months before this tour. In the fourth and final Test, he was Australian captain.

But he has been implicated by Bancroft now.

In his own 2022 autobiography, Paid claimed he had no knowledge of the use of sandpaper.

“Everyone out there was shocked when they looked up on the big screen and saw Cameron Bancroft with a piece of sandpaper in his hand,” he wrote.

“I was stunned. We all were. My heart sank, I was thinking, ‘What the f***?’ A sense of dread came over us all.”

Bancroft said wicketkeeper Paine was one of the players he was relying on for feedback while tampering with the Kookaburra.

“I also spoke with Tim Paine, who was in a key position behind the stumps to observe how the ball was moving,” he wrote.

“I wanted and needed feedback. How else am I to know if what I’m doing is effective or not if I don’t have these conversations with the bowlers bowling with it and the wicketkeeper?”

Khawaja revealed he, Bancroft and Paine were the three players sitting in off-shoot of the Australian dressing room at Cape Town.

Paine hasn’t responded to the fresh claims made by Khawaja or Bancroft, but he will be compelled to front press next month — if not earlier — in his role as Adelaide Strikers coach.

Pat Cummins

When Cummins stood before a heaving media throng and answered questions until they ran dry at Cricket Central in Sydney last month, he looked and sounded statesmanlike, emphatic and compelling.

Bancroft’s account makes him looks like the captain of a sinking ship, clinging on to a story as more and more players give evidence to the contrary.

In three separate statements across three days, Cummins’ manager Neil Maxwell has pointed fans and pundits to that 70-minute press conference and says the Aussie skipper will not speak again.

But there a contradictions from his story with Bancroft’s, including the batter’s claims Cummins was giving him feedback along the way. The heat is rising on the fast bowler to speak again, with former teammate Mitchell Johnson predicting his captaincy will not survive the latest developments in the scandal in his column for The West Australian and The Nightly.

If he doesn’t speak off his own bat, he is almost certain to the day before the first Test against New Zealand in Perth.

The support of Bancroft is so fervent in WA that Cummins faces the very real prospect of being peppered with boos as he enters the field to start a Test summer. It would be symbolic of this mess.

Australian Cricket Captain and NSW Blues player Pat Cummins during NSW Blues training in Sydney, Thursday, November 19, 2026. The sand paper ball tampering scandal continues after Cameron Bancroft made a statement yesterday that the whole Australian cricket team during the 2018 South African test knew about the ball tampering. (AAP Image/Dean Lewins) NO ARCHIVING
Australian Cricket Captain and NSW Blues player Pat Cummins during NSW Blues training in Sydney, Thursday, November 19, 2026. The sand paper ball tampering scandal continues after Cameron Bancroft made a statement yesterday that the whole Australian cricket team during the 2018 South African test knew about the ball tampering. (AAP Image/Dean Lewins) NO ARCHIVING Credit: DEAN LEWINS/AAPIMAGE

Josh Hazlewood

The Test quick has not responded to Bancroft’s latest allegations, including when contacted by The West on Friday.

He told a panel show months after returning from South Africa he was not aware of the use of sandpaper, but since the 2021 statement, he has stood behind that line.

“No, no (we didn’t know). We obviously have ball maintenance people in the team, usually batsmen because they’re in the circle and the bowlers field fine-leg, deep square — wherever it is,” Hazlewood said.

“They just look after the ball from time to time. As soon as it stops swinging normal then it starts to reverse swing. We pretty much get the ball at the stop of our mark, one second before we start running in. So we have a quick look, see which side’s a bit worn.”

The workhorse quick will likely front media during the Test series.

Nathan Lyon

Lyon was a signatory to the bowlers’ statement with the fellow members of Australia’s historic cartel, despite not being an exponent of reverse swing.

That’s the only time he has addressed the matter. Lyon — who welcomed a child with wife Emma this week — was contacted by The West on Friday.

Chadd Sayers

A one-Test quick, a domestic cricket veteran and an otherwise forgotten member of the touring squad, Sayers had a day to himself in the headlines last Sunday when he came out in support of Khawaja and Warner’s claims.

“I’m comfortable saying where I’m sitting now that everyone knew what was going on,” he told SEN, while working as an expert during the ODI in his hometown Adelaide.

“Sandpaper was used in two Test matches and there were discussions in change rooms. I’m not taking sides, it’s just my recollection of what took place.”

Sayers was the 12th man in Cape Town before playing his lone Test in the following match. He recalled collecting sandpaper off Bancroft while carrying water in the second Test.

Mitchell Starc

Starc has not responded to Bancroft’s account, but it is understood the legendary left-arm quick is weighing up his options.

The statesman of the Test team did dip his toes in after the release of Khawaja’s autobiography. At a season launch for broadcaster Kayo, he pointed back to the 2021 statement.

“Obviously, there’s differing opinions of eight years ago. We were heavily grilled through the process at the time, and since, and I guess I won’t speak on behalf of the bowlers, but where I stand, my opinion hasn’t changed,” he said.

“My recollection hasn’t changed from what we said in 2021.”

As heat rises on captain Cummins, pressure also mounts on his fellow bowlers. As it stands, their stances are tightly linked.

Mitchell Starc has bluntly denied Usman Khawaja's version of events relating to Sandpapergate. (Dean Lewins/AAP PHOTOS)
Mitchell Starc has bluntly denied Usman Khawaja's version of events relating to Sandpapergate. (Dean Lewins/AAP PHOTOS) Credit: Dean Lewins/AAP

Jon Holland

The reserve spinner and the least conspicuous member of the touring squad, Victorian Jon Holland actually made sandpaper revelations they were cool.

In an interview ahead of Australia’s return to South Africa in October, Hollands praised Warner for putting his hand up in a story that matches Khawaja’s about a team debrief after Bancroft was caught.

“Once we got back to the hotel, we did sit as a group about what happened and who was going to take the blame and to Davey’s credit, from what I remember he put his hand up and said he would take some of the responsibility, but not all of it,” he told News Corp.

“As a player who’s not contracted to Australia, who is sort of there as a second spinner in and out, for me I was in a different position.

“But to be sitting there and to just see three blokes sort of hung out to dry, when you are supposed to be a part of the team, it was a hard watch.”

Comments

Latest Edition

The Nightly cover for 20-11-2026

Latest Edition

Edition Edition 20 November 202620 November 2026

How Jess Wilson took the Victorian Liberals from political punchline to government in waiting.