‘Magical thinking’: Sovereign citizens clog Australian courts as judges battle bizarre pseudolaw claims
Australian courts are battling a surge of sovereign citizen claims as AI helps litigants create bogus legal arguments, dragging out hearings, inundating court staff and fuelling fears over threats to judges.

An onslaught of bizarre pseudolegal arguments and “magical thinking” from sovereign citizens is clogging Australian courts, with artificial intelligence fuelling a new and more disruptive phenomenon dubbed “pseudolaw Mark II”.
Judges are confronting increasingly belligerent and vexatious litigants, marathon hearings, courtroom intimidation and threats of violence as pseudolaw adherents attempt to use bogus legal arguments to escape fines, mortgages and taxes.
Sovereign citizens including Dezi Freeman and Wayne Glew have made headlines for challenging judicial authority, while a supporter of Angela Georganas famously attempted to arrest a South Australian judge during a courtroom confrontation.
Sign up to The Nightly's newsletters.
Get the first look at the digital newspaper, curated daily stories and breaking headlines delivered to your inbox.
By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.One of Australia’s leading pseudolaw researchers, Associate Professor Joe McIntyre, said pseudolaw extended far beyond the movement’s most notorious members.
“It’s not just crimes, so it’s traversing the full gamut of engagement with the state,” he told The Nightly.
“We see it in judicial review proceedings, in planning applications, in contract disputes and in a lot of estate matters.
“It does happen in more serious crimes, but the place we will often see a lot of it — and this is an Australian distinction — is in traffic offences.”

Such encounters have become a popular genre on TikTok, where motorists film confrontations with police while insisting traffic laws do not apply to them.
Dr McIntyre, from Adelaide University’s School of Law, said pseudolaw adherents genuinely believed they have discovered secret legal loopholes allowing them to avoid their obligations.
“It looks like law, but it’s a completely different set of rules and principles,” he said.
“So they think they’re doing law, but they’re actually operating in an almost parallel legal universe.”
He said adherents were often drawn to the movement after losing faith in legal institutions.
“It may be that they’ve got a massive tax bill, or they’re running into mortgage repayment issues, or there’s been a breakdown of a relationship,” he said.
“Something has really affected a degree of radicalisation, and COVID did that to a huge number of people with those public health measures.
“Suddenly we saw law being a coercive force that it had never been before, and then people were trying to find ways that they could avoid the force of law without – in their mind – becoming lawbreakers.”
The attraction of pseudolaw, he explained, was a form of “magical thinking” promising an escape from financial and legal troubles.
“It lets you avoid your mortgage, it lets you avoid your tax, and you’re not a bad person,” he said.
“You’re not a lawbreaker. Actually, you’re honouring the law.
“That presents a really compelling story for people.”
Common arguments include that laws require personal consent, that governments or judicial appointments are invalid, and that a person’s physical body is separate from an artificial legal identity created at birth.
Under the so-called “strawman” theory, adherents believe refusing to acknowledge their official identity can release them from legal obligations.
Dr McIntyre described the various claims as a “bucket of strange ideas why the laws might be invalid”.
Despite repeatedly failing in Australian courts, such arguments are consuming vastly disproportionate resources.
“It’s not just the number of these applications; it’s the impact of every single one of them,” he said.
“So generally, when we get self-represented litigants, they are passionate about their topic, but they’re quite intimidated by the engagement with the court, and there’s a degree of deference at play.
“What we get with pseudo-law litigants is their behaviour is really confrontational and belligerent, and there’s this belief that actually the judge is wrong, so they are the people with the accurate knowledge of the law.”
Adherents often regard an unfavourable decision as further proof of a conspiracy, provoking repeated appeals and challenges.
“What might, in normal circumstances, be a one-hour hearing, can really quickly turn into 3, 4 or 5-day hearings, or spread out over multiple weeks, and every point is taken up on appeal,” Dr McIntyre said.
“So it clogs everything up, and so we’re seeing judgement times are blowing out in some jurisdictions by a nearly doubling of judgement times by just the amount of this.
“It’s just completely blocking up the system.”
The disruption affects everyone from ordinary litigants waiting for hearings to registry employees handling an avalanche of correspondence.
“Court registry staff are getting inundated with so many emails that they’re often having to insist that they will only deal with paper applications and old snail mail applications to try and slow things down a little bit,” Dr McIntyre said.
“So this is really clogging up the legal system, and that was just the straight pseudo law.”
Dr McIntyre led one of the world’s most detailed empirical studies of pseudolaw, identifying 69 cases in South Australia’s published court records between 1973 and 2024. There were 50 per cent more cases in the most recent decade than in the preceding 40 years combined.
“We can confidently say that this was happening on a daily basis in South Australian courts and we were hearing the impact there that it is having on individual judges, and the threat and the concern about their safety and their impact on workplace health and well-being,” he said.
“That was demonstrated in South Australia, but everything we are seeing elsewhere says that that is consistent with what is being experienced elsewhere. South Australia is absolutely not in any way unusual in this.”
During a 2023 South Australian Supreme Court estate dispute involving Angela Georganas, sister of federal Labor MP Steve Georganas, the court heard allegations of “necromancy, witchcraft, sorcery and treason”.
A supporter rose from the public gallery and declared Judge Katrina Bochner under arrest before 45 supporters stood up and advanced towards her.
“Stand down, Judge Bochner, you are concealing treason against the King of England … you are now charged, you are under arrest,” the supporter said, according to The Advertiser.
“You are trading in necromancy, you are treating dead people in this courtroom.”
Dr McIntyre said members of the crowd had advanced towards the judge, who withdrew from the courtroom, and supporters later chased a court employee across Adelaide’s Victoria Square.
“That threat of violence is present, but it’s that low-level belligerence and aggression that’s just driving the judges to despair,” he said.
Another notorious sovereign citizen was Dezi Freeman, who previously challenged court authority and attempted to arrest a Victorian magistrate.
Freeman became the subject of a massive manhunt after two police officers were fatally shot at Porepunkah in August 2025. He was fatally shot by police in March this year.

In WA, former police officer Wayne Glew repeatedly challenged government authority, including refusing to pay council rates because he claimed local government was unconstitutional.
Leonard Casley, who styled himself Prince Leonard of the self-proclaimed Hutt River Province, challenged the tax office for decades, suffering a final court defeat in 2017, two years before his death. His son and “successor”, Graeme, dissolved the principality and sold the WA farmland to settle the ATO debt.

And in June 2025, Western Australian sovereign citizen couple Jerald Martin and Emma Hazel Martin were each sentenced to 30 days in jail for contempt of court after defying Supreme Court orders.
The increase in pseudolaw cases led to the Supreme Court of Victoria introducing new rules in September allowing registry staff to reject documents relying on pseudolegal claims.
The practice note identifies eight categories of arguments already rejected by Australian courts, including claims that laws require consent or that the Magna Carta overrides modern legislation.
It also warns against relying on social media misinformation or AI-generated legal advice.
Dr McIntyre praised the Victorian Supreme Court’s new practice note but warned artificial intelligence was creating an even more disruptive generation of pseudolaw litigants.
“These are now people who are not necessarily being driven by the internet forums and the chat groups,” he said.
“These are people who are using ChatGPT and presenting things that look like law but are not law.
“Their lawyer in their pocket is more right than the judge on the bench.
“So this is effectively pseudo law, Mark II, but this is much more diffuse and disruptive.”
In a September speech to an international judicial conference in Kyoto, NSW Chief Justice Andrew Bell warned pseudolaw threatened courts through an extraordinary administrative burden, the fragmentation of established law and the use of courtrooms for political theatre.
“The resolution of those claims, bearing in mind the need to maintain procedural fairness, takes up the time and resources of the court and diverts those resources from resolution of legitimate legal complaints and cases,” he said.
“This strategy has sometimes been described as ‘paper terrorism’.”
Justice Bell said arguments were repeatedly rejected and repackaged, with the process likened to the arcade game “whack-a-mole”.
“I am not aware of any court globally which has accepted or been positively influenced by a sovereign citizen argument,” he said.
South Australia’s Courts Administration Authority told The Nightly it regularly encountered parties advancing sovereign citizen and pseudolegal arguments.
“While the Courts Administration Authority does not separately record or maintain statistics on these matters, the experience of the Courts indicates that they have become more prevalent in recent years,” a spokesperson said.
“These arguments can consume significant Court and registry resources, particularly when they involve repetitive challenges to the authority or jurisdiction of the court, voluminous material, or a refusal to follow established court procedures.”
“Court resources are finite and need to be directed towards legitimate issues of fact and law.”
The ACT Courts and Tribunal confirmed encountering such litigants.
“Invariably, cases involving such claims will be more resource demanding and may involve multiple hearings,” a spokesperson said.
In an interview last year, WA Chief Justice Quinlan said he had personally encountered sovereign citizens and warned that growing rejection of judicial authority threatened the “safety and the stability of our society”.
“The impact on court staff can be very pronounced because they’re at the coalface, they’re on the registries, on the other end of the phones, they’re in the court buildings with people,” he told the ABC.
“It can have a very significant adverse impact on court staff having to deal with people who … can become very agitated by the fact that their view of what the law is does not accord with what the law actually is.”
Dr McIntyre warned that Australia’s courts needed stronger powers to manage disruptive proceedings, including reforms to vexatious litigant laws and potentially separate lists for pseudolaw matters.
“This is a systematic problem that needs systematic solutions, and we have still relied too much on the judgement and intervention of individual judges,” he said.
“We’re probably well beyond that now.”
