EDITORIAL: Backpacker backflip another case of back-to-front policy making that plagues Albanese Government
EDITORIAL: Backpacker policy revamp a step in the right direction, but another example of the back-to-front policy making of a chaotic Albanese Government.
The Albanese Government’s backpacker backflip is a step in the right direction.
But the need to remake the original policy — which was announced as recently as September — is yet another example of the shambolic approach which has become one of the Government’s defining characteristics.
The initial controversial plan to crack down on backpackers was part of an overhaul designed to rein in migration as One Nation’s popularity surged, with cutting migration at the centre of the minor party’s plan to reduce pressure on housing and services.
Sign up to The Nightly's newsletters.
Get the first look at the digital newspaper, curated daily stories and breaking headlines delivered to your inbox.
By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.But that move, by Immigration Minister Tony Burke, brought immediate warnings about labour shortfalls in the agriculture, tourism and hospitality sectors, including from the WA and SA Governments.
After weeks of pressure, Mr Burke announced a backflip on Tuesday.
It will increase backpackers’ regional work requirements for second-year visas from 88 days to 120 days and lift the proposed 5000-person cap on third-year visas to 25,000.
The changes don’t impact UK backpackers — who were released from regional work obligations after a 2023 free trade deal which allows them to remain in Australia for three years without requiring specific work to be undertaken.
Mr Burke said his concessions would still deliver the Government’s net overseas migration target of 245,000 this year and 225,000 in 2027-28 and beyond.
But some industries which had raised concerns about the initial plan said it had already damaged Australia’s appeal for working holiday makers, and the backflip did not go far enough.
Victorian Farmers’ Federation president Ryan Milgate said the saga had been completely unnecessary.
He said the backpackers were temporary visitors who did valuable work, “spend their wages in regional towns and tourism businesses, and then they go home”.
Mr Burke said the changes reflected consultation with the industries which said they would be impacted.
Incredibly, he highlighted how this had taken place after he had released the initial plan in a September speech.
“From the day after the speech … we started consultation with industry to work through what is the best landing place,” he said.
And there you have it.
Another case of the back-to-front policy making which has dogged the Albanese Government since its May Budget.
It has too often been a case of announce a policy and then work out the finer points later.
And of course some of the finer points were never going to fly.
The backpacker backflip was the Government’s sixth policy reversal in about a year, including on superannuation and Budget taxes on estate planning, tech start-ups and widows inheriting an investment property, and the tax office’s credit card payment ban.
Anthony Albanese has over time proudly declared that his was “an orderly Government” that would be in contrast to the disorder of the previous Coalition administration.
Instead we have endured months of dysfunction, policy on the run, backflips and half-baked plans which needed immediate revamps.
It has become the opposite of Mr Albanese’s boast and the very model of how not to run an orderly government.
